| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 WrestleCade WrestleCade 2018 - Supershow
Nov 24th 2018 | Carlito & Eddie Edwards | def. | Moose & MVP | | |
House of Hardcore #50
Sep 3rd 2018 | Billy Gunn & Carlito | def. | Dave Dawson & Zane Dawson | | |
House of Hardcore #40
Apr 7th 2018 | MVP | def. (pin) | Carlito | | |
Aro Lucha Lubbock Show
Jan 20th 2018 | Low Ki | def. | Carlito, James Storm | three-way | |
Aro Lucha Amarillo Show
Jan 19th 2018 | Juventud Guerrera & Super Crazy | def. | Carlito & James Storm | | |
House of Hardcore #36 - Blizzard Brawl Homecoming
Dec 2nd 2017 | Nick Aldis | def. | Carlito | | |
WrestleCade WrestleCade 2017 - Supershow
Nov 25th 2017 | Billy Gunn | def. | Carlito | | |
 House of Hardcore #31
Jun 24th 2017 | Carlito | def. | Matt Basso | | |
House of Hardcore #30
Jun 23rd 2017 | Carlito | def. | The Mighty Cadman | | |
House of Hardcore #29
Jun 18th 2017 | Bull James | def. | Carlito, Tommy Dreamer | triple-threat | |
House of Hardcore #28
Jun 17th 2017 | Carlito | def. | Ryan Nemeth | | |
House of Hardcore #27
Jun 16th 2017 | Carlito | def. | Jack Bonza | | |
WrestleCade WrestleCade 2016 - The Final 3 Count
Nov 26th 2016 | Carlito | def. | Jeff Jarrett | referee: Nick Patrick | |
Heroes & Legends VII
Oct 22nd 2016 | Carlito | def. | Jake Omen | | |
House of Hardcore XVI
Aug 6th 2016 | Carlito | def. | J. J. Blake | | |
House of Hardcore XV: Melbourne
Jun 24th 2016 | Carlito | def. (pin) | Andy Phoenix, KrackerJak, Tommy Dreamer | Hardcore (4-way) | |
 RevPro Live in Portsmouth
Feb 17th 2016 | Carlito | def. | Rob Lias | | |
VPW Vendettaversary VI
Aug 8th 2015 | Matt Riviera (c) | def. (pin) | Carlito Colon | | NWA Western States Heavyweight Championship
|
VPW Melee Tour '15 - Night 3
May 17th 2015 | Carlito Colon | def. (pin) | Ricardo Rodriguez | | |
VPW Melee Tour '15 - Night 2
May 16th 2015 | Carlito Colon | def. (pin) | Rik Luxury | special challenge | |
VPW Melee Tour '15 - Night 1
May 15th 2015 | Carlito Colon | def. (pin) | Dylan Drake | | |
House of Hardcore VIII
Mar 7th 2015 | Matt Hardy | def. (pin) | Carlito, Lance Hoyt | three-way | |
WrestleCade WrestleCade 2014
Nov 29th 2014 | Sonjay Dutt | def. | Carlito, D'Angelo Dinero | three-way | |
FWE ReFueled - Night 2
Oct 4th 2014 | Candice LeRae & Joey Ryan | def. (pin) | Carlito & Christina Von Eerie | | |
FWE ReFueled - Night 1
Oct 3rd 2014 | Drew Galloway | def. (pin) | Carlito | | |
 AWR Tour 2014 - Day 3
Sep 27th 2014 | Carlito | def. | Chris Masters | | |
AWR Tour 2014 - Day 2
Sep 26th 2014 | Carlito | def. | Chris Masters | | |
AWR Tour 2014 - Day 1
Sep 25th 2014 | Carlito | def. | Chris Masters | | |
Heroes & Legends IV
Sep 13th 2014 | Dru Skillz (c) | def. | Carlito | | HLW Championship
|
House of Hardcore VI: West Coast Invasion
Jun 14th 2014 | Matt Hardy | def. (pin) | Carlito, Tommy Dreamer | TLC (3-way) | |
DREAMWAVE Retaliation 2014
May 3rd 2014 | Aaron Xavier & Bucky Collins & Mallaki Matthews | def. | Carlito & Dan Lawrence & Judd the Janitor | 6-person tag | |
WrestleCade WrestleCade 2013
Nov 30th 2013 | Matt Hardy | def. | Carlito | ladder | Wrestlecade Championship
(title change) |
House of Hardcore #3
Nov 9th 2013 | Carlito & Rosita | def. (pin) | Stevie Richards & Tara | | |
FWE Openweight Grand Prix
Oct 12th 2013 | Tommy Dreamer | def. | Carlito | | |
RevPro Summer Sizzler 2013
Aug 18th 2013 | Carlito | def. | Sha Samuels | | |
AAW Scars and Stripes 2013
Jul 27th 2013 | Keith Walker | def. | Carlito | | |
House of Hardcore #2
Jun 22nd 2013 | Carlito | def. (pin) | Mike Bennett | | |
FWE Welcome to the Rumble 2
Jun 21st 2013 | John Morrison | def. | Carlito (c) | | FWE Heavyweight Championship
(title change) |
 NWE The Wrestling Show
May 25th 2013 | Carlito | def. | Sam Elias | | |
FWE No Limits 2013
Feb 16th 2013 | Carlito (c) | def. | Matt Hardy, Tommy Dreamer | TLC (3-way) | FWE Heavyweight Championship
|
House of Hardcore Debut Show
Oct 6th 2012 | Carlito | def. (pin) | Mike Knoxx (c), Tommy Dreamer (c) | three-way | FWE Heavyweight Championship
(title change) |
JCW Bloodymania 6
Aug 12th 2012 | Zach Gowen | def. | Bobby Lashley, Carlito, Chris Masters, Rude Boy, Shockwave the Robot, The Weedman, U-Gene, X-Pac | battle royale | |
FWE X
Jul 28th 2012 | Tommy Dreamer | def. | Brian Kendrick, Carlito, Jay Lethal (c) | fatal 4-way elimination | FWE Heavyweight Championship
(title change) |
FWE Dysfunctional Family
Jun 9th 2012 | Jay Lethal (c) | def. | Carlito, Tommy Dreamer | three-way hardcore | FWE Heavyweight Championship
|
PWS Fight Night: The 4 Year Anniversary Event
Aug 20th 2011 | Eddie Kingston | def. | Carlito | | |
JCW Legends & Icons
Aug 12th 2011 | Zach Gowen | def. | Brutus Beefcake, Carlito, Disco Inferno, Doink the Clown (Borne), Headbanger Mosh, Headbanger Thrasher, Jim Duggan, Jimmy Snuka, Rikishi, Rob Conway, Ronnie Garvin, Tony Atlas, U-Gene, Viscera | battle royale | |
 AAA Rey de Reyes 2011
Mar 18th 2011 | Extreme Tiger | def. (pin) | Carlito Carribean Cool, El Mesias, L. A. Park | four-way elimination | |
VPW Reflexion '11
Mar 12th 2011 | Carlito Colon | def. (pin) | Billy Blade | | |
 IGF Inoki Bob-Ba-Ye 2010
Dec 3rd 2010 | Kendo Ka Shin | def. | Carlito | | |
LL USA Masked Warriors #7
Aug 5th 2010 | Carlitos & P. R. Flyer & San Juan Kid | def. | El Oriental & Neutronic & Tinieblas Jr. | 6-person tag | |
San Juan, Puerto Rico, Puerto Rico
Carlito
