| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 IWA-MS Tryout Show #2: Feast or Famine
Nov 29th 2008 | Kareem Abdul Jamar | def. | Chris Mayne | | |
IWA-MS February Fury 2009
Feb 6th 2009 | Gameboy & Jimmy Shalwin | def. | Anthony Henry & Dustin Knight, Chris Mayne & Kareem Abdul Jamar, Frankie the Face & Jeff King | fatal 4-way tag | |
IWA-MS Winter Wars 2009
Feb 7th 2009 | Marshe Rockett & Trauma | def. | Anthony Henry & Dustin Knight & Bryan Skyline & Jeff Brooks & Chris Havius & Stephen Saint & Chris Mayne & Kareem Abdul Jamar & Frankie the Face & Jeff King & Gameboy & Jimmy Shalwin | Gauntlet (tag) | |
CHIKARA An Optimistic View of a Pessimistic World
Oct 17th 2009 | Amasis & Ophidian | def. | Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson, Chuck Taylor & Icarus, Dasher Hatfield & Sugar Dunkerton | four-way elimination tag | |
CHIKARA Cibernetico Incredible
Oct 18th 2009 | Dasher Hatfield & Sugar Dunkerton | def. | El Hijo del Ice Cream & Ice Cream Jr. | | |
CHIKARA Throwing Life's Instructions Away
Nov 21st 2009 | Dasher Hatfield & Sugar Dunkerton | def. | Chuck Taylor & Icarus | | |
CHIKARA Three-Fisted Tales
Nov 22nd 2009 | Brodie Lee & Colin Delaney & STIGMA & Vin Gerard | def. | Carpenter Ant & Dasher Hatfield & Green Ant & Sugar Dunkerton | 8-person tag | |
CHIKARA A Touch of Class
Jan 31st 2010 | Create-A-Wrestler & Player Uno & Sugar Dunkerton | def. (pin) | Colin Delaney & STIGMA & Vin Gerard | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA The Mint Condition
Feb 27th 2010 | Ares & Claudio Castagnoli | def. (pin) | Dasher Hatfield & Sugar Dunkerton | | |
CHIKARA A World of Comforting Illusions
Feb 28th 2010 | Dasher Hatfield & Sugar Dunkerton | def. (pin) | STIGMA & Vin Gerard | | |
AIW Jack of All Trios - Night 2
Apr 10th 2010 | Pinkie Sanchez & Tim Donst | def. | Matt Classic & Sugar Dunkerton | | |
FIP Southern Stampede '10
Apr 17th 2010 | Caleb Konley | def. | Craig Classic, Johnny Vandal, Ronnie the Red, STIGMA, Sugar Dunkerton | six-way wild card match | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '10: Night 1
Apr 23rd 2010 | Chuck Taylor & Gran Akuma & Icarus | def. (pin) | Dasher Hatfield & Matt Classic & Sugar Dunkerton | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '10: Night 3
Apr 25th 2010 | STIGMA & Vin Gerard | def. (pin) | Dasher Hatfield & Sugar Dunkerton | tag team gauntlet | |
CHIKARA Aniversario Zehn
May 22nd 2010 | Daizee Haze & Tursas | def. | Dasher Hatfield & Sugar Dunkerton | | |
CHIKARA Anniversario Elf
May 23rd 2010 | Dasher Hatfield & Jigsaw & Mike Quackenbush & Sugar Dunkerton | def. | Daizee Haze & Pinkie Sanchez & Sara Del Rey & Tursas | 8-person tag | |
FIP Crystal River Show (Jun '10)
Jun 26th 2010 | Chasyn Rance | def. | Sugar Dunkerton | | |
CHIKARA Young Lions Cup '10 - Day 1
Aug 27th 2010 | Christin Able | def. (pin) | Sugar Dunkerton | | |
CHIKARA Young Lions Cup '10 - Day 3
Aug 29th 2010 | Johnny Gargano | def. | Amasis, Brodie Lee, Cheech Hernandez, Claudio Castagnoli, Colin Delaney, Daizee Haze, Dasher Hatfield, Delirious, Eddie Kingston, Equinox II, Fire Ant, Grizzly Redwood, Icarus, Jervis Cottonbelly, Jigsaw, Mike Quackenbush, Ophidian, Pinkie Sanchez, Player Dos, Sara Del Rey, Scott Parker, Shane Matthews, Soldier Ant, Steve Weiner, STIGMA, Sugar Dunkerton, Ultramantis Black, Vin Gerard, Vokoder | "Countdown Showdown" | |
CHIKARA Scornucopia
Nov 20th 2010 | Acid Jaz & Marshe Rockett & Sugar Dunkerton & Willie Richardson | def. | Ares & Daizee Haze & Pinkie Sanchez & Tursas | 8-person tag | |
FIP Jeff Peterson Memorial Cup '10 - Day 1
Dec 3rd 2010 | Sugar Dunkerton | def. | Scott Reed | | |
FIP Jeff Peterson Memorial Cup '10 - Day 2
Dec 4th 2010 | Jon Moxley | def. | Sugar Dunkerton | | |
CHIKARA Reality is Relative
Dec 12th 2010 | Dasher Hatfield & Sugar Dunkerton | def. | Brodie Lee & Grizzly Redwood | | |
CHIKARA Chaos in the Sea of Lost Souls
Jan 23rd 2011 | Brodie Lee & Grizzly Redwood | def. | Dasher Hatfield & Sugar Dunkerton | | |
CHIKARA Caught in a Cauldron of Hate
Feb 19th 2011 | Brodie Lee | def. (CO) | Sugar Dunkerton | | |
Sugar Dunkerton