| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AAW Unstoppable 2016
Dec 30th 2016 | Sami Callihan (c) | def. | Rey Fenix | | AAW Heavyweight Title
|
House of Hardcore #22
Dec 16th 2016 | Sami Callihan | def. (sub) | Brian Cage | | |
CZW Cage of Death 18
Dec 10th 2016 | Lio Rush | def. | Sami Callihan | | |
House of Hardcore 21: Blizzard Brawl
Dec 3rd 2016 | Sami Callihan | def. (sub) | Bob Holly | | |
IWA-MS Big Ass Christmas Bash 2016
Dec 1st 2016 | Sami Callihan | def. | Jake Parnell | | |
AAW Windy City Classic XII
Nov 26th 2016 | Sami Callihan (c) | def. (sub) | Chris Hero | | AAW Heavyweight Title
|
CZW Night of Infamy 2016
Nov 19th 2016 | Joe Gacy | def. | Sami Callihan | | |
JAPW 20th Anniversary Show
Nov 12th 2016 | Alberto El Patron | def. (sub) | Sami Callihan | | |
Beyond/WWR Tournament For Today - Finals
Nov 6th 2016 | Anthony Gangone & Darius Carter & Devin Blaze & Tommy Trainwreck | def. (pin) | Dave Crist & Dezmond Xavier & Sami Callihan & Zachary Wentz | 8-person tag | |
IWA-MS Ted Petty Invitational 2016
Nov 5th 2016 | Cole Radrick | def. (sub) | Sami Callihan | | |
AAW Never Say Die 2016
Nov 4th 2016 | Eddie Kingston & Homicide & Low Ki | def. (pin) | Dave Crist & Jake Crist & Sami Callihan | 6-person tag | |
Wrestling Revolver Iowa Goes Lucha
Oct 28th 2016 | Brian Cage | def. (pin) | Sami Callihan | | |
EVOLVE #71
Oct 16th 2016 | Ethan Page | def. (pin) | Sami Callihan | | |
House of Hardcore XX
Oct 15th 2016 | Rhino | def. | Sami Callihan | | |
House of Hardcore XIX
Oct 14th 2016 | Bob Holly | def. | Sami Callihan | | |
AAW Jim Lynam Memorial Tournament - Day 2
Oct 8th 2016 | Jake Crist & Sami Callihan | def. (pin) | Fénix & Pentagon Jr. (c) | Title vs. Career vs. Hair vs. Mask Tag Team Match | AAW Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
AAW Jim Lynam Memorial Tournament - Day 1
Oct 7th 2016 | Pentagon Jr. (c) | def. | Sami Callihan | "Mexican Death" | AAW Heavyweight Title
|
IWA-MS 20th Anniversary Show
Oct 6th 2016 | Sami Callihan | def. | Cole Radrick | | |
 FCP Project Mayhem V
Sep 23rd 2016 | Pete Dunne | def. | Sami Callihan (c) | | FCP Title
(title change) |
House of Hardcore #18
Sep 17th 2016 | Ricochet | def. (pin) | Sami Callihan | | |
AAW Defining Moments 2016
Sep 16th 2016 | Sami Callihan | def. (pin) | Abyss | | |
CZW Down With The Sickness 2016
Sep 10th 2016 | Rickey Shane Page | def. | Sami Callihan | | |
PWG Battle of Los Angeles '16 - Night 3
Sep 4th 2016 | Cedric Alexander & Chuck Taylor & Jeff Cobb & Jushin Thunder Liger & Tommy End | def. (pin) | Brian Kendrick & Matt Riddle & Pete Dunne & Sami Callihan & Tommaso Ciampa | 10-person tag | |
PWG Battle of Los Angeles '16 - Night 2
Sep 3rd 2016 | Cody Rhodes | def. (pin) | Sami Callihan | | |
AAW Cero Miedo
Sep 1st 2016 | Fénix | def. (DQ) | Sami Callihan | | |
NEW Thunder
Aug 28th 2016 | Cody Rhodes | def. | Sami Callihan | | |
NEW Wrestling Under The Stars V
Aug 27th 2016 | Matt Hardy | def. (pin) | Sami Callihan | | |
AAW Showdown
Aug 19th 2016 | John Morrison | def. | Sami Callihan | | |
FCP International Tekkers: The Beginning Of The End
Aug 12th 2016 | Sami Callihan (c) | def. | Travis Banks | | FCP Title
|
PWG Thirteen
Jul 29th 2016 | Marty Scurll | def. (sub) | Sami Callihan | | |
AAW United We Stand 2016
Jul 23rd 2016 | Pentagon Jr. | def. (pin) | Sami Callihan (c) | | AAW Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
FCP Rage Against The Death Machine
Jul 8th 2016 | Sami Callihan | def. | Trent Seven | | FCP Title
(title change) |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 40: Ultima Lucha Tres Part 4
Jun 26th 2016 | Mil Muertes | def. (pin) | Cage, Jeremiah Crane | three-way elimination | |
AAW Killers Among Us 2016
Jun 17th 2016 | Dave Crist & Sami Callihan | def. | Eddie Kingston & Homicide | | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 36: The Rise of the Ring Announcer
Jun 12th 2016 | Kevin Kross | def. | Jeremiah Crane | dark
| |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 36: The Rise of the Ring Announcer
Jun 12th 2016 | Candice LeRae & Joey Ryan | def. | Jeremiah Crane & Jessicka Havok | dark
| |
Wrestling Revolver The Debut
Jun 10th 2016 | Bob Holly | def. (pin) | Sami Callihan | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 30: Super Strong Style 16 Tournament Edition 2016 - Day 2
May 30th 2016 | Tommy End | def. | Sami Callihan | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 30: Super Strong Style 16 Tournament Edition 2016 - Day 1
May 29th 2016 | Sami Callihan | def. | Matt Cross | | |
PWG Prince
May 20th 2016 | Roderick Strong | def. (pin) | Sami Callihan | | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 30: Bloodlines
May 15th 2016 | Mil Muertes | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Crane | | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 26: A Fenix to a Flame
May 14th 2016 | Jeremiah Crane | def. | Taya | | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 24: Macho Madness
May 8th 2016 | Jeremiah Crane | def. | Killshot | | |
AAW Take No Prisoners 2016
May 6th 2016 | Sami Callihan (c) | def. | Tommaso Ciampa | | AAW Heavyweight Title
|
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 17: The Gauntlet
Apr 24th 2016 | Jeremiah Crane | def. (pin) | Mil Muertes | | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 16: The Battle of the Bulls
Apr 23rd 2016 | The Mack | def. | Cage, Jeremiah Crane, P. J. Black | four-way elimination | |
House of Hardcore #13
Apr 16th 2016 | Brian Cage | def. (pin) | Sami Callihan | | |
House of Hardcore #12
Apr 15th 2016 | Billy Gunn | def. (pin) | Sami Callihan | | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 15: En La Sombra
Apr 10th 2016 | Jeremiah Crane | def. | Dante Fox, Killshot, Mariposa | four-way | |
Lucha Underground TV Taping - Season 3 Episode 11: Aztec Warfare III
Apr 9th 2016 | Sexy Star | def. (pin) | Dr. Wagner, Jr., Drago, Famous B, Jack Evans, Jeremiah Crane, Joey Ryan, Johnny Mundo, Kobra Moon, Mariposa, Marty Martinez, Mascarita Sagrada, Mil Muertes, P. J. Black, Pentagon Dark, Rey Mysterio, Ricky Mandel, Son of Havoc, The Mack, The Monster Matanza Cueto (c) | Aztec Warfare | Lucha Underground Championship
(title change) |
Sami Callihan during 2016