| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 BML Illusion II
Dec 29th 2005 | A.J. Styles | def. | Petey Williams | | |
 PWG Astonishing Xmas
Dec 16th 2005 | Chris Sabin & Frankie Kazarian & Rocky Romero & T. J. Perkins | def. | Alex Koslov & B-Boy & Christopher Daniels & Petey Williams | 8-person tag | |
TNA Turning Point '05
Dec 11th 2005 | A-1 & Bobby Roode & Eric Young & Petey Williams | def. (pin) | B. G. James & Kip James & Konnan & Ron Killings | 8-person tag | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Nov 28th 2005 | Chris Sabin | def. | Alex Shelley, Austin Aries, Petey Williams | four-way | |
PWG All Star Weekend 2: Electric Boogaloo - Day 2
Nov 19th 2005 | Chris Sabin & Frankie Kazarian | def. | Petey Williams & The Hardkore Kidd | | |
PWG All Star Weekend 2: Electric Boogaloo - Day 1
Nov 18th 2005 | Petey Williams | def. | Chris Sabin | | |
TNA Genesis '05
Nov 13th 2005 | A.J. Styles | def. (pin) | Petey Williams | | NWA X-Division Title
|
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Oct 25th 2005 | Petey Williams | def. | Chris Sabin, Matt Bentley | "Ultimate X" three-way | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Oct 25th 2005 | Petey Williams | def. (pin) | A.J. Styles | | |
TNA Bound For Glory '05
Oct 23rd 2005 | Petey Williams | def. | Chris Sabin, Matt Bentley | "Ultimate X" three-way | |
PWG Straight to DVD
Oct 14th 2005 | Davey Richards (c) & Super Dragon (c) | def. | Chris Sabin & Petey Williams | | PWG Tag Team Titles
|
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Sep 27th 2005 | Chris Sabin | def. | Alex Shelley, Petey Williams | triple-threat | |
TNA Unbreakable
Sep 11th 2005 | Chris Sabin | def. (pin) | Petey Williams | | |
PWG Smells Like Steen Spirit
Aug 19th 2005 | El Generico (c) & Human Tornado (c) | def. | Frankie Kazarian & Petey Williams | | PWG Tag Team Titles
|
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Aug 16th 2005 | Konnan & Lance Hoyt | def. (pin) | Kip James & Petey Williams | | |
TNA Sacrifice '05
Aug 14th 2005 | A-1 & Bobby Roode & Eric Young & Petey Williams | def. (pin) | Andy Douglas & Chase Stevens & Chris Harris & James Storm | 8-person tag | |
JCW Gathering of the Juggalos 2005: JCW vs. TNA - Day 2
Jul 23rd 2005 | Terry Funk | def. | 2 Tuff Tony (c), A-1, Abyss, Chris Harris, Corporal Robinson, D-Ray 3000, James Storm, Jeff Jarrett, Kid Kash, Mad Man Pondo, Petey Williams, Rhino, Sabu, Shaggy 2 Dope, The Blue Meanie, Violent J | Battle Royal | JCW Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
JCW Gathering of the Juggalos 2005: JCW vs. TNA - Day 1
Jul 22nd 2005 | D-Ray 3000 & Petey Williams | draw (NC) | Shaggy 2 Dope & Violent J | | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Jul 19th 2005 | Petey Williams | def. | Chris Sabin | | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Jul 19th 2005 | A.J. Styles | def. | Petey Williams | | |
TNA No Surrender '05
Jul 17th 2005 | Christopher Daniels (c) | def. (pin) | Petey Williams | | NWA X-Division Title
|
PWG 2nd Annual Bicentennial Birthday Extravaganza - Day 2
Jul 10th 2005 | Chris Sabin & Petey Williams | def. | Joey Ryan & Scott Lost | | |
PWG 2nd Annual Bicentennial Birthday Extravaganza - Day 1
Jul 9th 2005 | Ricky Reyes | def. | Petey Williams | | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Jun 21st 2005 | Petey Williams | def. | The Amazing Red | | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Jun 21st 2005 | Eric Young & Petey Williams | def. (pin) | Christopher Daniels & Samoa Joe | | |
Windsor, Ontario, Canada
Petey Williams during 2005