| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 DREAMWAVE Open Roads, Broken Dreams
May 2nd 2009 | G. T. Vega | def. | Nick Cutler | | |
AAW A Reign of Violence 2009
Aug 15th 2009 | Krotch | def. | Nick Cutler | | |
AAW Unleashed 2009
Aug 21st 2009 | Krotch | def. | Nick Cutler | | |
OVW TV Taping #650
Feb 1st 2012 | Brandon Espinosa | def. (pin) | Nick Cutler | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #653
Feb 22nd 2012 | Jack Black & Joe Coleman | def. (pin) | Nick Dumeyer & Rick Cutler | | |
OVW TV Taping #654
Feb 29th 2012 | Jessie Godderz | def. | Nick Cutler | dark
| |
Heroes & Legends V
Jul 25th 2015 | Troy Miller | def. | Andrew S. Kirk, Eli McFly, Jack Thriller, Nick Cutler, Owen Travers | 6-Way | HLW Cruiserweight Championship
(title change) |
Heroes & Legends VI
Mar 26th 2016 | Russ Jones | def. | Nick Cutler | | |
FIP Declaration of Independence 2016
Jul 8th 2016 | Greg Glover & Nick Cutler | def. | Ace Andrews & Rex Bacchus | | |
Heroes & Legends Fitness Fest
Aug 27th 2016 | Russ Jones | def. | Nick Cutler | | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Sep 26th 2016 | Cesaro & Sheamus | def. (pin) | Nick Cutler & Willis Williams | | |
FIP All or Nothing 2016
Sep 30th 2016 | Earl Cooter | def. | Nick Cutler | | |
Heroes & Legends VII
Oct 22nd 2016 | Nick Cutler | def. (pin) | Kongo Kong | | |
Heroes & Legends IX
Nov 11th 2017 | Nick Cutler | def. | Jack Swagger | | |
Black Label Pro First of the Month
Dec 1st 2017 | Mance Warner | def. | Allie Kat, Darin Corbin, Kobe Durst, Matt Knicks, Nick Cutler, Shane Sabre, Stevie Fierce, The Space Monkey | "Scramble" | |
House of Hardcore #36 - Blizzard Brawl Homecoming
Dec 2nd 2017 | Little Guido Maritato | def. | Nick Cutler | | |
Heroes & Legends X
Apr 21st 2018 | James Ellsworth | def. | Nick Cutler | | |
House of Hardcore #41
Apr 28th 2018 | Nick Cutler (c) | def. | Matt Cross | | WFW Children's Title
|
Heroes & Legends XI
Oct 27th 2018 | Sugar Dunkerton (c) | def. | Nick Cutler | | HLW Cruiserweight Championship
|
Heroes & Legends XII
Apr 20th 2019 | Nick Cutler | def. | Anthony Toatele, Unknown Participants | Battle Royal | |
Heroes & Legends XII
Apr 20th 2019 | Kongo Kong (c) | def. (pin) | Nick Cutler, Russ Jones | three-way | HLW Championship
|
Heroes & Legends XIII
Oct 5th 2019 | Anthony Toatele | def. | Kongo Kong (c), Nick Cutler, Officer Rod Street, Russ Jones | 5-way | HLW Championship
(title change) |
Heroes & Legends Professional Wrestling The Way It Should Be
Nov 9th 2019 | Nick Cutler | def. | Shane Mercer | | |
Heroes & Legends X8 Tournament
Feb 1st 2020 | Nick Cutler | def. | Benjamin Boone | | |
Heroes & Legends X8 Tournament
Feb 1st 2020 | Anthony Toatele | def. | Nick Cutler | | |
Nick Cutler