| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 WWE Night of Champions '09
Jul 26th 2009 | Michelle McCool (c) | def. (pin) | Melina | | WWE Women's Championship (original)
|
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Jul 1st 2009 | Eve Torres & Melina | def. | Layla & Michelle McCool | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Jun 30th 2009 | Maria Kanellis & Melina | def. | Layla & Michelle McCool | | |
WWE The Bash '09
Jun 28th 2009 | Michelle McCool | def. (pin) | Melina (c) | | WWE Women's Championship (original)
(title change) |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Jun 23rd 2009 | Alicia Fox & Michelle McCool | def. | Gail Kim & Melina | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Jun 9th 2009 | Layla & Michelle McCool | def. | Eve Torres & Melina | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Jun 2nd 2009 | Alicia Fox & Layla & Michelle McCool | def. (pin) | Eve Torres & Gail Kim & Melina | 6-person tag | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
May 19th 2009 | Michelle McCool | def. (pin) | Gail Kim | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
May 12th 2009 | Gail Kim & Melina | def. (pin) | Alicia Fox & Michelle McCool | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
May 5th 2009 | Michelle McCool | def. | Gail Kim | | |
WWE Superstars Taping pt. 2
Apr 28th 2009 | Alicia Fox & Michelle McCool | def. (pin) | Gail Kim & Maria Kanellis | | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Apr 13th 2009 | Maryse & Michelle McCool & Natalya | def. (pin) | Kelly Kelly & Melina & Mickie James | 6-person tag | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Apr 7th 2009 | Gail Kim | def. (pin) | Michelle McCool | | |
WWE WrestleMania XXV
Apr 5th 2009 | Santina | def. | Alicia Fox, Beth Phoenix, Brie Bella, Eve Torres, Gail Kim, Jackie Gayda, Jillian Hall, Joy Giovanni, Katie Lea Burchill, Kelly Kelly, Layla, Maria Kanellis, Maryse, Melina, Michelle McCool, Mickie James, Molly Holly, Natalya, Nikki Bella, Rosa Mendes, Sunny, Tiffany, Torrie Wilson, Victoria | Battle Royal | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Mar 30th 2009 | Alicia Fox & Brie Bella & Eve Torres & Gail Kim & Kelly Kelly & Maria Kanellis & Melina & Mickie James & Tiffany | def. (pin) | Beth Phoenix & Jillian Hall & Katie Lea Burchill & Layla & Maryse & Michelle McCool & Natalya & Nikki Bella & Rosa Mendes | 18-diva tag | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Mar 30th 2009 | Gail Kim & Maria Kanellis | def. (pin) | Maryse & Michelle McCool | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Mar 17th 2009 | Maryse (c) | draw (NC) | Michelle McCool | | WWE Divas Championship
|
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Mar 3rd 2009 | Maria Kanellis & Melina | def. (pin) | Maryse & Michelle McCool | | |
 WWE WWE Live (Smackdown)
Feb 21st 2009 | Nikki Bella | def. | Michelle McCool | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Feb 17th 2009 | Maryse & Michelle McCool | def. (pin) | Eve Torres & Maria Kanellis | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Feb 10th 2009 | Maria Kanellis | def. (pin) | Michelle McCool | | |
WWE WWE Live
Feb 8th 2009 | Eve Torres & Maria Kanellis | def. (pin) | Michelle McCool & Natalya | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Jan 27th 2009 | Michelle McCool | def. (sub) | Eve Torres | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Jan 13th 2009 | Michelle McCool | def. (pin) | Victoria | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Jan 13th 2009 | Michelle McCool & Natalya | def. (DQ) | Brie Bella & Nikki Bella | | |
Michelle McCool during 2009