| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 IWA-MS Candido Cup 2008
Dec 6th 2008 | Michael Elgin & Sami Callihan | def. | Bryan Skyline & Jeff Brooks | | |
IWA-MS Candido Cup 2008
Dec 6th 2008 | Acid Jaz & Marshe Rockett | def. | Michael Elgin & Sami Callihan | | |
IWA-MS Wrestling with a Heart
Dec 20th 2008 | Michael Elgin | def. | Kris Chambers | | |
IWA-MS Out With the Old, In With the New 2009
Jan 3rd 2009 | Michael Elgin & Sami Callihan | def. | Bryan Skyline & Jeff Brooks, Christin Able & Josh Raymond, Corey Mason & Kris Chambers, Devin Cutter & Mason Cutter, Gameboy & Jimmy Shalwin, Greg Excellent & Jeff King, Ian Rotten & Mickie Knuckles | tag team battle royale | |
IWA-MS Out With the Old, In With the New 2009
Jan 3rd 2009 | Roderick Strong | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
IWA-MS TV Taping
Jan 17th 2009 | Michael Elgin | def. | Jeff Brooks | | |
IWA-MS TV Taping
Jan 17th 2009 | Michael Elgin | def. | Jason Hades | | |
IWA-MS February Fury 2009
Feb 6th 2009 | Bryan Skyline & Jeff Brooks | def. | Michael Elgin & Sami Callihan | tag team ladder | |
IWA-MS Winter Wars 2009
Feb 7th 2009 | Michael Elgin | def. | Devon Moore | | |
IWA-MS King of the Deathmatch '09: Night 1
Mar 6th 2009 | Dingo (c) | def. | Michael Elgin | "Old School IWA Rules" | IWA:MS Heavyweight Title
|
IWA-MS King of the Deathmatch '09: Night 2
Mar 7th 2009 | Devon Moore & Nick Gage | def. | Jason Hades & Tank, Bull Pain & Egotistico Fantastico, Alex Colon & D. J. Hyde, EZE & Prince Mustafa Ali, Juice Robinson & Michael Elgin, Elkview Adam & Nate Webb | tag team battle royale | |
IWA-MS March Massacre 2009
Mar 20th 2009 | Michael Elgin | def. | Jon Moxley | | |
IWA-MS April Bloodshowers 2009 - Day 1
Apr 3rd 2009 | Michael Elgin | def. | Bill the Butcher, Jon Moxley, Keith Walker | four-way | |
IWA-MS April Bloodshowers 2009 - Day 2
Apr 4th 2009 | Keith Walker | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
 ROH Tag Title Classic
Apr 18th 2009 | Alex Payne & Player Uno | def. | Ash & Michael Elgin | dark
| |
IWA-MS Spring Heat
May 2nd 2009 | Devin Cutter & Mason Cutter | def. | Michael Elgin & Sami Callihan | | |
IWA-MS Spring Heat
May 2nd 2009 | Acid Jaz & Marshe Rockett | def. | Michael Elgin & Sami Callihan | | |
IWA-MS Turn Back the Clock
May 3rd 2009 | Marshe Rockett | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
IWA-MS Bad Blood Rising 2009
May 16th 2009 | Larry Sweeney | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
IWA-MS Opportunity
May 22nd 2009 | Keith Walker | def. | Michael Elgin | "Last Man Standing" | |
IWA-MS A Cold Day In May
May 23rd 2009 | Drake Younger | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
IWA-MS No Retreat, No Surrender 2009
Jun 5th 2009 | Carter Gray | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
IWA-MS Truth, Justice, and the IWA Way
Jun 6th 2009 | Atsushi Sawada | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
IWA-MS Benefit for Acid Jaz
Jun 7th 2009 | Michael Elgin | def. | Ethan Page | | |
IWA-MS Kings of the Crimson Mask 2009
Aug 28th 2009 | Jimmy Jacobs | def. | Michael Elgin | Dog Collar Match | |
AAW My Bloody Valentine 2010
Feb 27th 2010 | Jay Bradley | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
Alpha-1 The Next Level
Apr 11th 2010 | Michael Elgin | def. | Cloudy | | |
Dragon Gate USA Uprising
May 8th 2010 | Kris Chambers & Michael Elgin | def. | Kenneth Crisis & Mike Rollins | | |
Capital City Championship Combat Crossing the Line III
Jun 18th 2010 | Brodie Lee | def. (pin) | Michael Elgin | | |
Alpha-1 Proving Ground
Jul 18th 2010 | Michael Elgin | def. | Alessandro Del Bruno | | |
Alpha-1 Proving Ground
Jul 18th 2010 | Michael Elgin | def. | Johnny Wave, Josh Alexander, Scotty O'Shea | four-way elimination | |
Alpha-1 Another Day In Paradise
Aug 15th 2010 | Michael Elgin | def. | Joey Kings | | |
2CW Saving Wrestling From Mediocrity ...One Fan at a Time
Sep 24th 2010 | J. Freddie | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
Alpha-1 The Final Act
Oct 24th 2010 | Justin Sane | def. | Brodie Lee, Cheech, Michael Elgin | four-way elimination | A1 Alpha Male Title
(title change) |
ROH Survival of the Fittest '10
Nov 12th 2010 | Christopher Daniels & Jay Briscoe & Mark Briscoe | def. | Michael Elgin & Roderick Strong & Zach Gowen | 6-person tag | |
ROH Fate of an Angel II
Nov 13th 2010 | Bobby Dempsey & Grizzly Redwood | def. | Michael Elgin & Zach Gowen | | |
OVW TV Taping #591
Dec 8th 2010 | Alex Silva | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Dec 9th 2010 | Michael Elgin | def. | Alex Silva | dark
| |
ROH TV Tapings
Dec 10th 2010 | Michael Elgin & Roderick Strong | def. | Alex Silva & Chrisjen Hayme | | |
OVW Saturday Night Special (December '10)
Dec 11th 2010 | Ryan Nemeth | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Jan 21st 2011 | Michael Elgin | def. | Bobby Dempsey | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Jan 22nd 2011 | Kyle O'Reilly | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
Alpha-1 Stage 2
Feb 20th 2011 | Michael Elgin | def. | Colin Delaney | | |
ROH World's Greatest
Feb 25th 2011 | Christopher Daniels | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
ROH 9th Anniversary Show
Feb 26th 2011 | El Generico | def. (pin) | Michael Elgin | | |
AAW 7th Anniversary Show
Mar 12th 2011 | Shane Hollister (c) | def. | Michael Elgin | | AAW Heritage Title
|
ROH Defy or Deny
Mar 18th 2011 | Eddie Edwards | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
ROH Manhattan Mayhem IV
Mar 19th 2011 | Adam Cole & Kyle O'Reilly | def. | Michael Elgin & Mike Mondo | | |
ROH Honor Takes Center Stage - Day 1
Apr 1st 2011 | Michael Elgin | def. | El Generico | | |
ROH Honor Takes Center Stage - Day 2
Apr 2nd 2011 | Christopher Daniels | def. | Michael Elgin | | |
Michael Elgin