| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 NXT Atlanta Show
Jan 4th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Adam Cole | | |
NXT Spartanburg Show
Jan 5th 2019 | EC3 & Keith Lee & Matt Riddle | def. | Bobby Fish & Kyle O'Reilly & Roderick Strong | 6-person tag | |
NXT Durham Show
Jan 6th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Adam Cole | | |
NXT Largo Show
Jan 10th 2019 | Keith Lee & Matt Riddle & Ricochet | def. | Johnny Gargano & Kassius Ohno & Shane Thorne | 6-person tag | |
NXT Orlando Show
Jan 12th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Shane Thorne | | |
NXT Venice Show
Jan 17th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Riddick Moss | | |
NXT San Diego Show
Jan 24th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Kassius Ohno | | |
NXT Riverside Show
Jan 25th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Kassius Ohno | | |
NXT TakeOver: Phoenix
Jan 26th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. (sub) | Kassius Ohno | | |
NXT TV Taping #335
Jan 30th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. (sub) | Drew Gulak | | |
NXT Orlando Show
Feb 1st 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Luke Menzies | | |
NXT Tom's River Show
Feb 7th 2019 | Danny Burch & Matt Riddle & Oney Lorcan | def. | Jaxson Ryker & Steve Cutler & Wesley Blake | 6-person tag | |
NXT Poughkeepsie Show
Feb 8th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. (sub) | Dominik Dijakovic | | |
NXT Lowell Show
Feb 9th 2019 | Danny Burch & Matt Riddle & Oney Lorcan | def. | Jaxson Ryker & Steve Cutler & Wesley Blake | 6-person tag | |
NXT Kingston Show
Feb 10th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. (sub) | Dominik Dijakovic | | |
NXT Bartow Show
Feb 14th 2019 | Matt Riddle & The Velveteen Dream | def. (pin) | Fabian Aichner & Marcel Barthel | | |
NXT St. Augustine Show
Feb 16th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Babatunde Aiyegbusi | | |
NXT Sebring Show
Feb 21st 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Babatunde | | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Feb 22nd 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. (sub) | Dominik Dijakovic | | |
NXT Tampa Show
Feb 28th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. (sub) | Riddick Moss | | |
NXT Jacksonville Show
Mar 2nd 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Riddick Moss | | |
NXT Largo Show
Mar 7th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Babatunde Aiyegbusi | | |
NXT Dade City Show
Mar 8th 2019 | Johnny Gargano & Matt Riddle | def. | Bobby Fish & Kyle O'Reilly | | |
NXT TV Taping #341
Mar 13th 2019 | Adam Cole | def. (pin) | Aleister Black, Matt Riddle, Ricochet, The Velveteen Dream | 5-way | |
NXT TV Taping #342
Mar 13th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. (sub) | Kona Reeves | | |
NXT Venice Show
Mar 15th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. (DQ) | Adam Cole | | |
NXT Ocala Show
Mar 16th 2019 | Matt Riddle & Mia Yim & Punishment Martinez | def. | Kyle O'Reilly & Marina Shafir & Roderick Strong | 6-person tag | |
NXT Sanford Show
Mar 21st 2019 | The Velveteen Dream (c) | def. | Matt Riddle | | NXT North American Championship
|
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Mar 23rd 2019 | The Velveteen Dream (c) | def. (pin) | Matt Riddle, Roderick Strong | triple-threat | NXT North American Championship
|
NXT TakeOver: New York
Apr 5th 2019 | The Velveteen Dream (c) | def. (pin) | Matt Riddle | | NXT North American Championship
|
WWE Wrestlemania Axxess 2019 - Day 4 - Worlds Collide: Brands Collide Taping
Apr 7th 2019 | Roderick Strong | def. | Akira Tozawa, Ariya Daivari, Brian Kendrick, Dave Mastiff, Dominik Dijakovic, Drew Gulak, Eric Bugenhagen, Fabian Aichner, Humberto Carrillo, Joe Coffey, Ligero, Mark Coffey, Matt Riddle, Rinku Singh, Saurav Gurjar, Steve Cutler, Travis Banks, Tyler Bate, Wesley Blake | Battle Royal | |
NXT TV Taping #348
Apr 10th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. (sub) | Adam Cole | | |
NXT Largo Show
Apr 12th 2019 | The Velveteen Dream (c) | def. | Adam Cole, Matt Riddle | triple-threat | NXT North American Championship
|
NXT TV Taping #350
May 1st 2019 | Bobby Fish & Kyle O'Reilly | def. | Johnny Gargano & Matt Riddle | | |
NXT West Palm Beach Show
May 3rd 2019 | The Velveteen Dream (c) | def. | Matt Riddle | | NXT North American Championship
|
NXT Fort Pierce Show
May 4th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Adam Cole | | |
NXT Sebring Show
May 10th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Punishment Martinez | | |
NXT St. Augustine Show
May 11th 2019 | Matt Riddle & Punishment Martinez | def. | Fabian Aichner & Marcel Barthel | | |
NXT Bethlehem Show
May 16th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Roderick Strong | | |
NXT Philadelphia Show
May 17th 2019 | The Velveteen Dream (c) | def. | Adam Cole, Matt Riddle | triple-threat | NXT North American Championship
|
NXT TV Taping #353
May 18th 2019 | The Velveteen Dream (c) | def. | Adam Cole, Matt Riddle | dark
triple-threat | NXT North American Championship
|
NXT Coral Gables Show
May 24th 2019 | Matt Riddle & The Velveteen Dream | def. | Steve Cutler & Wesley Blake | | |
NXT Daytona Beach Show
May 25th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Trevor Lee | | |
NXT TakeOver XXV
Jun 1st 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. (sub) | Roderick Strong | | |
NXT TV Taping #354
Jun 12th 2019 | Adam Cole & Bobby Fish & Roderick Strong | def. (pin) | Matt Riddle & The Velveteen Dream & Tyler Breeze | 6-person tag | |
NXT TV Taping #358 Part 2
Jun 13th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Arturo Ruas | | |
 NXT UK TV Tapings - Download Festival 2019 - Day 2
Jun 15th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | Ilja Dragunov | dark
| |
NXT UK TV Tapings - Download Festival 2019 - Day 3
Jun 16th 2019 | Matt Riddle | def. | James Drake | dark
| |
NXT San Antonio Show
Jun 20th 2019 | Adam Cole (c) | def. | Matt Riddle | | NXT Championship
|
NXT Houston Show
Jun 21st 2019 | Matt Riddle & The Velveteen Dream | def. | Dan Matha & Riddick Moss | | |
Matt Riddle during 2019