| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 WWE NXT Redemption Taping #43
Jan 3rd 2012 | Maxine | def. | Kaitlyn | | |
FCW TV Tapings (January '12 #1)
Jan 12th 2012 | Audrey Marie & Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Raquel Diaz & Sofia Cortez | | |
FCW Orlando Show (January '12)
Jan 18th 2012 | Audrey Marie & Kaitlyn | def. | Raquel Diaz & Sofia Cortez | | |
FCW Tampa Show (January '12 #2)
Jan 19th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. | Sofia Cortez | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #48
Feb 7th 2012 | Maxine | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn | | |
FCW Tampa Show (February '12 #2)
Feb 16th 2012 | Audrey Marie & Kaitlyn | def. | Paige & Sofia Cortez | | |
FCW TV Tapings (February '12 #2)
Feb 23rd 2012 | Audrey Marie & Kaitlyn | def. (sub) | Paige & Sofia Cortez | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #51
Feb 28th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Maxine | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #53
Mar 13th 2012 | Derrick Bateman & Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Johnny Curtis & Maxine | | |
FCW Miami Show (March '12)
Mar 16th 2012 | Sofia Cortez | def. | Audrey Marie, Kaitlyn, Paige | "Money in the Bank" | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #56
Apr 3rd 2012 | Natalya | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn | | |
 WWE NXT Redemption Taping #58
Apr 17th 2012 | Maxine | def. (sub) | Kaitlyn | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #59
Apr 24th 2012 | Kaitlyn & Tamina Snuka | def. | Maxine & Natalya | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
May 8th 2012 | AJ | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #62
May 15th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Maxine | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #64
May 29th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Tamina Snuka | | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown)
Jun 2nd 2012 | A.J. Lee | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn | | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown)
Jun 3rd 2012 | A.J. Lee | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn | | |
WWE NXT Redemption Taping #66
Jun 12th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Natalya | | |
NXT TV Taping #5
Jun 13th 2012 | Tamina Snuka | def. | Kaitlyn | | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Jun 25th 2012 | AJ | def. | Aksana, Alicia Fox, Beth Phoenix, Kaitlyn, Layla, Maxine, Natalya, Rosa Mendes, Tamina Snuka, Vickie Guerrero | Battle Royal | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown)
Jul 7th 2012 | Vickie Guerrero | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn | referee: AJ | |
WWE Superstars Taping
Jul 9th 2012 | Alicia Fox & Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Beth Phoenix & Natalya | | |
NXT TV Taping #8
Jul 11th 2012 | Paige & Tamina Snuka | def. (pin) | Caylee Turner & Kaitlyn | | |
WWE Money in the Bank '12
Jul 15th 2012 | Kaitlyn & Layla & Tamina Snuka | def. (pin) | Beth Phoenix & Eve Torres & Natalya | 6-person tag | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown)
Jul 21st 2012 | Natalya | def. (sub) | Kaitlyn | | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown)
Jul 22nd 2012 | Natalya | def. (sub) | Kaitlyn | | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown)
Jul 28th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Natalya | | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown)
Jul 29th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Natalya | | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Aug 13th 2012 | Kaitlyn & Layla | def. (pin) | Beth Phoenix & Eve Torres | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Aug 14th 2012 | Eve Torres | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn | | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Aug 20th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. | Aksana, Alicia Fox, Eve Torres, Natalya, Rosa Mendes, Tamina Snuka | Battle Royal | |
NXT TV Taping #17
Aug 22nd 2012 | Audrey Marie & Paige | def. | Alicia Fox & Kaitlyn | | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown)
Aug 26th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Natalya | | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Aug 28th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Natalya | | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
Sep 3rd 2012 | Eve Torres | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn | | |
 WWE Monday Night Raw
Sep 10th 2012 | Eve Torres & Kaitlyn & Layla | def. (pin) | Alicia Fox & Beth Phoenix & Natalya | 6-person tag | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Sep 11th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Beth Phoenix | | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown)
Sep 29th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Natalya | | |
WWE WWE Live (Smackdown)
Sep 30th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Natalya | | |
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Oct 5th 2012 | Eve Torres (c) | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn, Layla | 3-way Match | WWE Divas Championship
|
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Oct 6th 2012 | Eve Torres (c) | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn, Layla | 3-way Match | WWE Divas Championship
|
WWE WWE Live (Raw)
Oct 7th 2012 | Eve Torres (c) | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn, Layla | 3-way Match | WWE Divas Championship
|
WWE Monday Night Raw
Oct 8th 2012 | Eve Torres (c) | def. (sub) | Kaitlyn | | WWE Divas Championship
|
WWE WWE Live
Oct 12th 2012 | Layla | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn | | |
WWE WWE Live
Oct 13th 2012 | Layla | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn | | |
WWE WWE Live
Oct 14th 2012 | Layla | def. (pin) | Kaitlyn | | |
WWE Superstars Taping
Oct 15th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Beth Phoenix | | |
 WWE WWE Live - Smackdown World Tour
Oct 18th 2012 | Kaitlyn | def. (pin) | Natalya | | |
WWE WWE Live - Smackdown World Tour
Oct 19th 2012 | Natalya | def. (sub) | Kaitlyn | | |
Kaitlyn during 2012