| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 OTT Christmas Invasion
Dec 18th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. | Fabian Aichner | | |
WCPW Loaded #18
Dec 1st 2016 | Trent Seven & Tyler Bate | def. | Alex Gracie & Lucas Archer, Joe Coffey & Mark Coffey | three-way tag elimination | |
WCPW Delete WCPW
Nov 30th 2016 | Johnny Moss & Liam Slater | def. | Joe Coffey & Mark Coffey | | WCPW Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
PROGRESS Chapter 39: The Graps of Wrath
Nov 27th 2016 | William Eaver | def. (pin) | Joe Coffey | | |
FCP Infinity 2016
Nov 25th 2016 | Trent Seven | def. | Joe Coffey, Mikey Whiplash, Omari | four-way | |
WCPW Loaded #15
Nov 9th 2016 | Joe Coffey & Mark Coffey | def. | Gabriel Kidd & Prince Ameen | dark
| |
WCPW Loaded #16
Nov 9th 2016 | Joe Coffey & Mark Coffey | def. | Pete Dunne & Travis Banks | | |
World of Sport New Years Eve 2016 Special Taping
Nov 1st 2016 | Grado | def. | British Bulldog Jr., El Ligero, Joe Coffey, Johnny Moss, Kenny Williams, Mark Coffey, Sha Samuels | Battle Royal | |
World of Sport New Years Eve 2016 Special Taping
Nov 1st 2016 | Joe Coffey & Mark Coffey | def. (pin) | Ashton Smith & Rampage | | |
FCP Pulp Fixxion - Part 1
Oct 21st 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. | Travis Banks | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 37: A Sudden Sense of Liberty
Oct 16th 2016 | Marty Scurll | def. | Joe Coffey, Pete Dunne, Trent Seven | four-way | |
WCPW True Legacy
Oct 8th 2016 | Minoru Suzuki | def. | Joe Coffey | | |
WCPW Loaded #13
Oct 7th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. | Big Damo | | |
WCPW Refuse to Lose
Oct 6th 2016 | Minoru Suzuki | def. | Joe Coffey | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 36: We're Gonna Need a Bigger Room... Again
Sep 25th 2016 | Rampage Brown | def. | Joe Coffey | | PROGRESS Atlas Title
(title change) |
WCPW Loaded #10
Sep 15th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. | Prince Ameen | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 35: Writing Nirvana On Other People's Bags
Aug 28th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. | Dave Mastiff | | |
WCPW Loaded #8
Aug 25th 2016 | Joe Hendry | def. | Doug Williams, Drew Galloway, El Ligero, Ethan Carter III, Joe Coffey, Liam Slater, Martin Kirby, Marty Scurll, Pete Dunne, Primate, Prince Ameen, Rampage, Travis Banks | Kurt Angle Invitational Rumble | |
WCPW Stacked
Aug 24th 2016 | Moose | def. | Joe Coffey | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 34: Keep It Unreal
Aug 13th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. | Michael Dante | | |
WCPW Loaded #7
Jul 28th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. (ref) | Primate | | |
WCPW Loaded #6
Jul 27th 2016 | Big Damo (c) | def. | Joe Coffey | | WCPW World Title
|
PROGRESS Chapter 31: All Hail the New Puritans
Jun 19th 2016 | Damo O'Connor & Joe Coffey | def. (pin) | Mikey Whiplash & Rampage Brown | | |
WCPW Loaded #4
Jun 16th 2016 | Big Damo & Joe Coffey | draw (NC) | Primate & Rampage | | |
WCPW Born to Destroy
Jun 16th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. | Primate | no holds barred | |
WCPW Loaded #3
Jun 16th 2016 | Joe Coffey | draw (NC) | Primate | | |
WCPW Loaded #1
Jun 15th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. (CO) | Prince Ameen | | |
 EVOLVE #63
Jun 11th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. (sub) | Rory Gulak | dark
| |
EVOLVE #62
Jun 10th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. | Eric Locker, Unknown Participants | dark
Gauntlet | |
CHIKARA Aniversario: The Lost World
May 30th 2016 | Nixon Newell & Trent Seven & Tyler Bate | def. (pin) | Joe Coffey & Lewis Girvan & Miss Viper | dark
6-person tag | |
 OTT Even Better Than Our Best
May 28th 2016 | Pete Dunne | def. | Joe Coffey | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 29: Practically PROGRESS In Every Way
Apr 24th 2016 | Joe Coffey | draw (time) | Rampage Brown | | |
PROGRESS Chapter 26: Unknown Pleasures
Feb 14th 2016 | Dave Mastiff & Zack Gibson | def. | Damian O'Connor & Joe Coffey, Chuck Mambo & William Eaver, Darrell Allen & Earl Black Jr. | four-way tag | |
5 Star UK Tour - Day 3
Jan 15th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. | Carlito | | |
5 Star UK Tour - Day 2
Jan 14th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. | Zack Sabre Jr. | | |
5 Star UK Tour - Day 1
Jan 13th 2016 | Joe Coffey | def. | Will Ospreay | | |
Joe Coffey during 2016