| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 ROH TV Tapings
Dec 4th 2016 | Jay Lethal | def. | Jushin Thunder Liger | | |
ROH Final Battle '16
Dec 2nd 2016 | Cody R. | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal | | |
 ROH Reach for the Sky - Day 3
Nov 20th 2016 | Adam Cole (c) | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal | | ROH World Heavyweight Title
|
ROH Reach for the Sky - Day 2
Nov 19th 2016 | Jay Lethal | def. | Alex Shelley | | |
ROH Reach for the Sky - Day 1
Nov 18th 2016 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Chris Sabin | | |
 NJPW Power Struggle 2016
Nov 5th 2016 | Tetsuya Naito (c) | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal | | IWGP Intercontinental Championship
|
ROH Road to Final Battle 2016 - Night 3: TV Tapings
Oct 29th 2016 | Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin & Jay White & Lio Rush | def. (pin) | Jay Briscoe & Jay Lethal & Mark Briscoe & Silas Young | 8-person tag | |
ROH Road to Final Battle 2016 - Night 2
Oct 22nd 2016 | Jay Lethal | def. | Kamaitachi | | |
ROH Road to Final Battle 2016 - Night 1
Oct 21st 2016 | Alex Shelley & Jay Lethal & Silas Young | def. | Christopher Daniels & Colt Cabana & Jay Briscoe | 6-person tag | |
ROH Glory By Honor XV - Day 2
Oct 15th 2016 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Frankie Kazarian | | |
ROH Glory By Honor XV - Day 1
Oct 14th 2016 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Matt Jackson | | |
NJPW King of Pro-Wrestling '16
Oct 10th 2016 | Hiroshi Tanahashi & Jay Lethal & KUSHIDA & Michael Elgin | def. (pin) | BUSHI & EVIL & SANADA & Tetsuya Naito | 8-person tag | |
NJPW New Japan Road ~ Ganbare! Uonuma 2016 ~
Oct 8th 2016 | Hiroshi Tanahashi & Jay Lethal & KUSHIDA & Michael Elgin | def. | BUSHI & EVIL & SANADA & Tetsuya Naito | 8-person tag | |
ROH All Star Extravaganza VIII - TV Tapings
Oct 1st 2016 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Silas Young | | |
ROH/NJPW All Star Extravaganza VIII
Sep 30th 2016 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Tetsuya Naito | | |
ROH Reloaded Tour 2016
Sep 24th 2016 | Jay Lethal | def. | Colt Cabana | Ringmaster Challenge (fall 1: pinfall; fall 2: submission; fall 3: 15-minute Ironman) | |
ROH Reloaded Tour 2016
Sep 17th 2016 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Adam Cole | | |
ROH Reloaded Tour 2016
Sep 17th 2016 | Silas Young | def. | Alex Shelley, Beer City Bruiser, Bull James, Caprice Coleman, Cheeseburger, Chris Sabin, Christopher Daniels, Frankie Kazarian, Hanson, Jay Lethal, Jay White, Kenny King, Lio Rush, Matt Jackson, Nick Jackson, Punisher Martinez, Raymond Rowe, Steve Corino, Unknown Participants | "Honor Rumble" | |
ROH Reloaded Tour 2016
Sep 17th 2016 | Jay Lethal | def. | Silas Young | | |
ROH Reloaded Tour 2016
Sep 16th 2016 | Colt Cabana & Dalton Castle & Jay Lethal | def. | Adam Cole & Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | 6-person tag | |
ROH Field of Honor
Aug 27th 2016 | Adam Cole (c) | def. (pin) | Hiroshi Tanahashi, Jay Lethal, Tetsuya Naito | four corners survival | ROH World Heavyweight Title
|
ROH Death Before Dishonor XIV: TV Tapings
Aug 20th 2016 | Jay Lethal & Kyle O'Reilly & Michael Elgin | def. | Adam Cole & Hangman Page & Yujiro Takahashi | 6-person tag | |
ROH Death Before Dishonor XIV
Aug 19th 2016 | Adam Cole | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal (c) | | ROH World Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
NJPW G1 Climax 26 - Day 19
Aug 14th 2016 | Jay Lethal (c) | def. (pin) | Satoshi Kojima | | ROH World Heavyweight Title
|
NJPW G1 Climax 26 - Day 18
Aug 13th 2016 | BUSHI & Jay Lethal & SANADA | def. (pin) | Hiroshi Tanahashi & KUSHIDA & Satoshi Kojima | 6-person tag | |
Jay Lethal during 2016