| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 WrestlePro Alaska: 4th Anniversary SuperShow
Apr 22nd 2023 | Dan Maff | def. | Bobby Wayward (c), Deonn Rusman, Jay Lethal | ladder (four-way) | WrestlePro Championship
(title change) |
AEW Rampage #89 Taping
Apr 19th 2023 | Cash Wheeler & Dax Harwood & Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | def. | Ari Daivari & Josh Woods & Slim J & Tony Nese | 8-person tag | |
AEW Rampage #88 Taping
Apr 12th 2023 | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett & Mark Briscoe & Satnam Singh | def. (pin) | Angélico & Luther & Man Scout & Serpentico | 8-person tag | |
ROH Honor Club TV #6 Taping
Apr 5th 2023 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Darius Martin | | |
AEW Dynamite #179
Mar 8th 2023 | Orange Cassidy (c) | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal | | AEW All-Atlantic Championship
|
AEW Revolution 2023
Mar 5th 2023 | Austin Gunn (c) & Colten Gunn (c) | def. (pin) | Anthony Bowens & Max Caster, Danhausen & Orange Cassidy, Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | four-way tag | AEW Tag Team Championship
|
AEW Dark #185 Taping - Part 2
Feb 26th 2023 | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett & Satnam Singh | def. (pin) | Jackson Drake & Jay Malachi & Oliver Sawyer | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dynamite #177
Feb 22nd 2023 | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | def. | Alex Reynolds & John Silver, Angelo Parker & Matt Menard, Ari Daivari & Tony Nese, The Blade & The Butcher, Chuck Taylor & Trent Beretta, Dante Martin & Darius Martin, Kyle Fletcher & Mark Davis, Penta El Zero Miedo & Rey Fenix, Preston Vance & Rush | tag team battle royale | |
AEW Dynamite #176
Feb 15th 2023 | Anthony Bowens & Daddy Ass & Max Caster & Orange Cassidy | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett & Satnam Singh & Sonjay Dutt | 8-person tag | |
WrestlePro Violencetines Day
Feb 11th 2023 | Jay Lethal | def. | CPA | | |
 Jericho Cruise Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea: Four Leaf Clover - Night 4
Feb 5th 2023 | Jay Lethal | def. | Ortiz | | |
Jericho Cruise Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea: Four Leaf Clover - Night 3
Feb 4th 2023 | Jay Lethal | def. | Moose | | |
AEW Dynamite #173
Jan 25th 2023 | Mark Briscoe | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal | | |
AEW Rampage #77 Taping
Jan 25th 2023 | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett & Satnam Singh | def. (pin) | Chuck Taylor & Danhausen & Trent Beretta | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dynamite #172
Jan 18th 2023 | Orange Cassidy (c) | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal | | AEW All-Atlantic Championship
|
AEW Battle of the Belts V
Jan 6th 2023 | Anthony Bowens (c) & Max Caster (c) | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | no holds barred tag | AEW Tag Team Championship
|
AEW Dynamite #170
Jan 4th 2023 | Anthony Bowens (c) & Max Caster (c) | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | | AEW Tag Team Championship
|
AEW Dark: Elevation #96 Taping
Dec 28th 2022 | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | def. (pin) | Justin Andrews & Ryzin | | |
AEW Rampage #72 - Holiday Bash Taping
Dec 21st 2022 | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | def. (pin) | Anthony Bowens & Daddy Ass | | |
AEW Rampage #69 Taping
Nov 30th 2022 | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | def. (pin) | Isiah Kassidy & Marq Quen | | |
BTW Return Of The Dragon
Nov 27th 2022 | Cash Wheeler & Dax Harwood & Ricky Steamboat | def. | Brock Anderson & Jay Lethal & Nick Aldis | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #91 Taping
Nov 23rd 2022 | Jay Lethal & Satnam Singh | def. (pin) | GPA & Joe Alonzo | | |
AEW Full Gear 2022
Nov 19th 2022 | Darby Allin & Sting | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett | no disqualification tag | |
AEW Dynamite #162
Nov 9th 2022 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Trent Beretta | | |
AEW Dark #173 Taping
Nov 4th 2022 | Jay Lethal & Satnam Singh | def. (pin) | JCruz & Victor Chase | | |
Jay Lethal