| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AEW Dark: Elevation #44 - Part 2 Taping
Dec 28th 2021 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Troy Hollywood | | |
ROH Final Battle 2021 - End of an Era
Dec 11th 2021 | Jonathan Gresham | def. (sub) | Jay Lethal | | ROH World Heavyweight Title
(title change) |
AEW Dynamite #114
Dec 8th 2021 | Dante Martin, MJF | def. | Frankie Kazarian, Jay Lethal, Lee Johnson, Lee Moriarty, Lio Rush, Matt Hardy, Matt Sydal, Powerhouse Hobbs, Ricky Starks, Wardlow | Dynamite Diamond Battle Royal | |
 AAA Triplemania Regia II
Dec 4th 2021 | El Hijo Del Vikingo | def. (pin) | Bandido, Bobby Fish, Jay Lethal, Samuray del Sol | 5-way | AAA Mega Championship
(title change) |
WrestleCade WrestleCade 2021 - Revenge
Nov 27th 2021 | Jay Lethal | def. | Matt Cardona | | |
ROH TV #532 (airdate)
Nov 26th 2021 | EC3 | def. (sub) | Jay Lethal | | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #39 Taping
Nov 24th 2021 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Trenton Storm | | |
AEW Dynamite #111
Nov 17th 2021 | Sammy Guevara (c) | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal | | AEW TNT Championship
|
ROH TV #527 - VLNCE vs. Pure (airdate)
Oct 22nd 2021 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Homicide | | |
ROH TV #526 (airdate)
Oct 15th 2021 | Jay Lethal & Jonathan Gresham & Rhett Titus & Tracy Williams | def. (sub) | Eli Isom & Joe Keys & Taylor Rust & World Famous CB | 8-person tag | |
ROH TV #523 (airdate)
Sep 24th 2021 | Brody King | def. | Jay Lethal, Kenny King, Shane Taylor | four corners survival | |
WrestlePro Great Alaskan Bash: Palmer (incomplete card)
Aug 27th 2021 | Jay Lethal | def. (sub) | Bobby Wayward | | |
WrestlePro Great Alaskan Bash: Anchorage
Aug 26th 2021 | Hollywood Nova & Jay Lethal & The Blue Meanie | def. | Brian Myers & Matt Cardona & V. S. K. | 6-person tag | |
ROH Glory By Honor 2021 - Day 2
Aug 21st 2021 | Jay Lethal & Jonathan Gresham & Rhett Titus & Tracy Williams | def. | Brody King & Chris Dickinson & Homicide & Tony Deppen | 8-person tag | |
ROH TV #513 (airdate)
Jul 16th 2021 | Kaun & Moses & O'Shay Edwards & Shane Taylor | def. | Jay Lethal & Joe Keys & Rhett Titus & Tracy Williams | 8-person tag | |
ROH Best in the World 2021
Jul 11th 2021 | Brody King | def. | Jay Lethal | | |
ROH TV #512 (airdate)
Jul 9th 2021 | Dragon Lee & Kenny King | def. (pin) | Brody King & Tony Deppen, Jay Lethal & Jonathan Gresham | three-way tag | |
ROH TV #506 (airdate)
May 28th 2021 | Brody King & Chris Dickinson & Homicide & Tony Deppen | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jonathan Gresham & Rhett Titus & Tracy Williams | 8-person tag | |
ROH TV #500 (airdate)
Apr 16th 2021 | Jonathan Gresham (c) | def. | Jay Lethal | pure wrestling | ROH Pure Wrestling Title
|
ROH TV #499 (airdate)
Apr 9th 2021 | Jay Lethal & Jonathan Gresham | def. (sub) | Bandido & Flamita | | |
ROH 19th Anniversary Show
Mar 26th 2021 | Rush (c) | def. | Jay Lethal | | ROH World Heavyweight Title
|
ROH TV #496 (airdate)
Mar 19th 2021 | Bestia Del Ring & Dragon Lee & Kenny King & Rush | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jonathan Gresham & Rhett Titus & Tracy Williams | 8-person tag | |
ROH TV #494 (airdate)
Mar 5th 2021 | Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | EC3, Jay Briscoe, Matt Taven | four-way | |
ROH TV #493 - Championship Edition (airdate)
Feb 26th 2021 | Dragon Lee & Kenny King | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal (c) & Jonathan Gresham (c) | | ROH World Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
ROH TV #491 (airdate)
Feb 12th 2021 | Jay Lethal & Rhett Titus & Wheeler YUTA | def. (pin) | Fred Yehi & Jonathan Gresham & Tracy Williams | 6-person tag | |
ROH TV #488 (airdate)
Jan 22nd 2021 | Kaun & Moses & Shane Taylor | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jonathan Gresham & Tracy Williams | 6-person tag | |
ROH TV #485 (airdate)
Jan 1st 2021 | Mark Haskins | def. (sub) | Jay Lethal | | |
Jay Lethal during 2021