| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 Glory Pro Sleep When We're Dead
Aug 20th 2017 | Barackus | def. | Aaron Dzinic, Calvin Tankman, Gary Jay, Jake Parnell, Matt Kenway, Matt Knicks, Stevie Fierce | Gauntlet | |
IWA-MS Ted Petty Invitational 2017 - Day 1
Sep 14th 2017 | Homicide | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Ted Petty Invitational 2017 - Day 2
Sep 15th 2017 | Gary Jay & Ludark Shaitan | def. | Anthony Henry & Shane Sabre | | |
Glory Pro Something Wicked
Oct 15th 2017 | Gary Jay | def. | Jake Parnell | | |
Wrestling Revolver Tales From the Ring
Oct 28th 2017 | Matt Palmer (c) | def. | Ace Austin, Clayton Jackson, Cole Radrick, Curt Stallion, Dave Crist, Gary Jay, Jake Manning, Johnny Ruckus, Jordan Len-X, Myron Reed, Paco Gonzalez, Tessa Blanchard | "Scramble" | PWR Scramble Title
|
Black Label Pro First of the Month
Dec 1st 2017 | Gary Jay | def. | Eric Ryan | | |
Freelance Wrestling Stained Glass Ceilings
Jan 12th 2018 | Darin Corbin | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Freelance Underground Baderbrawl 4: It's Wrestling (& Football) in the Brewery
Feb 4th 2018 | Craig Mitchell (c) | def. | Gary Jay | | FU Heavyweight Title
|
Glory Pro One Year Anniversary
Feb 18th 2018 | Jake Parnell | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Opposite Sides of the Track
Mar 1st 2018 | Jake Parnell | def. | Gary Jay | | |
CZW Proving Grounds 2018
Mar 10th 2018 | Wheeler YUTA | def. | Gary Jay, Mike Verna | three-way | |
IWA-MS Ragin (Not In The) Cajun
Apr 5th 2018 | Gary Jay | def. | Dale Patricks | | |
AIW Ain't Nuthin But a Gangsta Party
Apr 20th 2018 | The Space Monkey | def. | Donovan Danhausen, Facade, Gary Jay | No countout no disqualification 4-way | |
IWA-MS Derby Madness 2018
May 3rd 2018 | Larry D | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Glory Pro Only The Strong Survive
May 6th 2018 | Jake Parnell | def. | Gary Jay | knockout match | |
Freelance Underground/GCW Freelance Underground vs. Game Changer Wrestling
May 12th 2018 | Nick Gage | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Prelude to Death 2018
May 17th 2018 | Kevin Lee Davidson | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Revolution Strong Style Tournament 2018
Jun 21st 2018 | Gary Jay | def. | Reed Bentley | | |
IWA-MS Revolution Strong Style Tournament 2018
Jun 21st 2018 | Gary Jay | def. | Bad Bones | | |
IWA-MS Revolution Strong Style Tournament 2018
Jun 21st 2018 | Matt Riddle | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Black Label Pro JAM
Jul 14th 2018 | Kobe Durst | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Don't Be A Menace
Jul 21st 2018 | Gary Jay | def. | Logan James | | |
EVOLVE #110
Aug 11th 2018 | Jake Parnell (c) | def. (pin) | Gary Jay | | ZERO-ONE USA X-Division Championship
|
IWA-MS Old Grudges Die Hard
Aug 16th 2018 | Gary Jay | def. | Larry D | | |
IWA-MS Prelude to Petty 2018
Sep 20th 2018 | Gary Jay | def. | Devon Moore | | |
IWA-MS Ted Petty Invitational 2018 - Day 1
Sep 21st 2018 | Mance Warner | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Ted Petty Invitational 2018 - Day 2
Sep 22nd 2018 | Calvin Tankman & Jake Lander & Jake Omen & Matt Kenway | def. | Gary Jay & Joey Owens & Shane Mercer & Tripp Cassidy | 8-person tag | |
IWA-MS Week 85
Oct 5th 2018 | Shane Mercer | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Glory Pro Horse Power
Oct 7th 2018 | Joey Lynch | def. | Gary Jay | | |
CZW Better Than Our Best
Oct 13th 2018 | Gary Jay | def. | Jake Parnell | | |
Black Label Pro Big Trouble in Little Crown Point
Nov 3rd 2018 | Kevin Ku | def. | Gary Jay | | |
CZW Night of Infamy 2018
Nov 10th 2018 | Kobe Durst | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Freelance Wrestling Sleepless In Chicago
Feb 1st 2019 | Kobe Durst | def. | Ari Azteca, Gary Jay, Jake Parnell | four-way | |
Black Label Pro Unplugged
Feb 2nd 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Tyler Bateman | | |
CZW Twenty
Feb 9th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | John Silver | | |
Black Label Pro Whoomp! There It Is!
Mar 9th 2019 | Jake Parnell (c) | def. | Gary Jay | "I Quit" | BLP Indiana State Title
|
IWTV Family Reunion
Apr 4th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Jake Parnell | "Last Man Standing" | |
Black Label Pro Adventures In Wrestling
Apr 5th 2019 | A. J. Gray & C. W. Anderson & Curt Stallion & Gary Jay | def. | Chris Dickinson & Daniel Makabe & Jake Parnell & Rory Gulak | 8-person tag | |
WrestlePro/CZW WrestlePro Vs. CZW
Apr 6th 2019 | Jordan Oliver | def. | Gary Jay, Jaxon Stone, Mr. Iguana | four-way | |
CZW Best of the Best 18
Apr 13th 2019 | John Silver | def. | Fred Yehi, Gary Jay, Kris Stadtlander | four-way | |
Black Label Pro Player's Brawl
Apr 20th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Anthony Greene | | |
CZW Tangled Web 2019
May 11th 2019 | Jimmy Lloyd | def. | Cole Radrick, Gary Jay | three-way | |
IWTV The Midwest Mixtape
May 26th 2019 | Craig Mitchell | def. | Gary Jay | street fight | |
Black Label Pro There's Something About Barry
Jun 1st 2019 | Ethan Page | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Black Label Pro Dropkicks & Dragons
Jul 27th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Tom Lawlor | | |
Black Label Pro McWrestling
Aug 24th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Alex Zayne | | |
Black Label Pro/GCW 2 Cups Stuffed
Aug 30th 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Warhorse | | |
Black Label Pro Turbo Graps 16 - Part 2
Sep 21st 2019 | Erick Stevens (c) | def. | Gary Jay, Jake Something, Tom Lawlor | four-way | IWTV Independent Wrestling Title
|
Black Label Pro Turbo Graps 16 - Part 1
Sep 21st 2019 | Gary Jay | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
IWA-MS The Show Must Go On
Nov 2nd 2019 | Kevin Giza | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Gary Jay