| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2013 - Day 1
May 24th 2013 | Davey Vega | def. | Gary Jay | | |
AIW Absolution VIII
Jun 30th 2013 | Briley & Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay | def. | Jock Samson & Marion Fontaine & Tracy Smothers | Bunkhouse Brawl (6-man tag) | |
AIW Gleaming the Cube
Aug 30th 2013 | Isabella Smothers & Tracy Smothers | def. | Briley & Gary Jay | | |
Wresting is... Intense - Before the Devil Knows You're Dead
Sep 15th 2013 | Gary the Barn Owl | def. (pin) | The Proletariat Boar of Moldova | | |
Beyond TV Taping
Dec 8th 2013 | Kerry Awful & Nick Iggy | def. | Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | | |
IWA-MS/EVO Pro For the Love of Leanna
Dec 22nd 2013 | Gary Jay | def. | Cash Flo | | |
AIW Dead Presidents
Dec 27th 2013 | Russ Myers (c) & T-Money (c) | def. | Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy, Josh Prohibition & Matt Cross, Briley & Gary Jay | four-way tag | AIW Tag Team Championship
|
IWA-MS Out With the Old, In With the New 2014
Jan 11th 2014 | Necro Butcher | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Heartbreak
Feb 8th 2014 | Gary Jay | def. | Davey Vega | | |
IWA-MS Hanging and Banging for Hatler
Feb 8th 2014 | Christian Rose & Gary Jay & Jordynne Grace | def. | Angelus Layne & Chris Hero & Davey Vega | 6-person tag | |
IWA-MS Sunday, Bloody Sunday
Mar 9th 2014 | Hy-Zaya & Matt Cage & Necro Butcher | def. | Gary Jay & Jack Thriller & Shane Mercer | 6-person tag | |
FIP Everything Burns 2014
Mar 14th 2014 | Eddie Graves & Johnny Vandal & Teddy Stigma | def. | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | 6-person tag | |
FIP Ascension 2014
Mar 15th 2014 | Gary Jay | def. | Aaron Epic | | |
IWA-MS/EVO Pro Benefit Show
May 18th 2014 | 2 Tuff Tony & Mad Man Pondo | def. | Gary Jay & Jack Thriller | | |
Wresting is... Fun! - Tag World Grand Prix 2014 - Night 3
May 24th 2014 | Joe Pittman | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Here We Go Again
May 29th 2014 | Gary Jay | def. | Moose | | |
IWA-MS Summer Classic
Jun 5th 2014 | Gary Jay | def. | American Viking | | |
IWA-MS Payback, Pain, and Agony
Jun 12th 2014 | Reed Bentley & Tripp Cassidy | def. | B.J. Whitmer & Hy-Zaya, Devin Cutter & Mason Cutter, Gary Jay & Shane Mercer | fatal 4-way tag | |
IWA-MS Somebody's Gonna Hurt Somebody
Jun 19th 2014 | Ace Perry | def. | Gary Jay | | |
CHIKARA Quantum of Solace
Jun 21st 2014 | Dasher Hatfield & Mark Angelosetti | def. (pin) | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Suicidal Tendencies
Jun 29th 2014 | Shane Mercer | def. | Ace Perry, Dale Patricks, Gary Jay, Jack Thriller, Joseph Schwartz, Reed Bentley, Tripp Cassidy | 8-way | |
FIP Declaration of Independence 2014
Jul 11th 2014 | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. | Aaron Epic & Davey Vega & Jason Cade | 6-person tag | |
IWA-MS An American Wolf in Clarksville
Jul 17th 2014 | Devin Cutter & Mason Cutter | def. | American Viking & Gary Jay, Dale Patricks & Johnny Rotten Sixx, Josh Crane & Tripp Cassidy | fatal 4-way tag | |
IWA-MS 600th Show
Aug 10th 2014 | B.J. Whitmer | def. | Ace Perry, Gary Jay, Reed Bentley, Shane Mercer | 5-way | |
FIP Fallout 2014
Sep 5th 2014 | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. (pin) | Eddie Graves & Jonny Vandal & Teddy Stigma | 6-person tag | |
Gary Jay