| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 CHIKARA Three-Fisted Tales
Nov 22nd 2009 | Delirious & Ultramantis Black | def. | Frightmare & Hallowicked | | |
CHIKARA Cibernetico Incredible
Oct 18th 2009 | Carpenter Ant & Cheech Hernandez & Hallowicked & Lince Dorado & Matt Jackson & Mike Quackenbush & Player Uno & Soldier Ant | def. | Fire Ant & Frightmare & Green Ant & Helios & Jigsaw & K. C. Day & Nick Jackson & Player Dos | 16-man tag elimination | |
CHIKARA An Optimistic View of a Pessimistic World
Oct 17th 2009 | Player Dos (c) | def. | Frightmare | | CHIKARA Young Lions Cup
|
CHIKARA Hiding in Plain Sight
Sep 13th 2009 | Frightmare & Hallowicked | def. | Chuck Taylor & Icarus | | |
CHIKARA Man Makes Plans and God Laughs
Sep 12th 2009 | Frightmare | def. | Brendan Michael Thomas | | |
CHIKARA Young Lions Cup '09 - Day 3
Aug 16th 2009 | Jorge Rivera & Mike Quackenbush | def. | Frightmare & Turbo | | |
CHIKARA Young Lions Cup '09 - Day 1
Aug 14th 2009 | Brendan Michael Thomas | def. | Frightmare | | |
CHIKARA Never Kneel at the Altar of Conformity
Jul 31st 2009 | Colin Delaney & STIGMA & Vin Gerard | def. | Frightmare & Hallowicked & Hydra | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA Anniversario Yang
May 24th 2009 | Cheech & Cloudy & Frightmare & Hallowicked | def. | Helios & Jigsaw & Lince Dorado & Mike Quackenbush | 8-person tag | |
CHIKARA Anniversario Yin
May 23rd 2009 | Frightmare & Hallowicked | def. | Jagged & Shane Matthews | | |
CHIKARA The Bobliographon
Apr 26th 2009 | Delirious & Frightmare & Hallowicked | def. | Brodie Lee & Eddie Kingston & Grizzly Redwood | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA Behind the 8 Ball
Apr 25th 2009 | Jagged & Shane Matthews | def. | Frightmare & Hallowicked | | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '09: Night 3
Mar 29th 2009 | Jigsaw & Mike Quackenbush | def. | Frightmare & Hallowicked, Ryan Drago & Tony Kozina, Hydra & Tim Donst, Crossbones & Ultramantis Black, Beef Wellington & Steven Weiner, Create-A-Wrestler & Player Uno, Mitch Ryder & Pinkie Sanchez, Marshe Rockett & Willie Richardson, Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson, Cheech & Cloudy, Brodie Lee & Grizzly Redwood | tag team gauntlet | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '09: Night 1
Mar 27th 2009 | Johnny Saint & Mike Quackenbush & Skayde | def. (pin) | Delirious & Frightmare & Hallowicked | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA Secret Delaware Show with Lucha Libre Mexicana
Mar 9th 2009 | Klondike Grizzly & STIGMA | def. | Cometa de Oro & Frightmare | | |
CHIKARA Motive, Means, Opportunity
Feb 21st 2009 | Ophidian | def. | Frightmare | | |
CHIKARA If the Airplane is Snowed In, Put your Bloody Skis On and Get Going!
Feb 20th 2009 | Brodie Lee | def. | Frightmare | | |
CHIKARA Revelation X
Jan 25th 2009 | Frightmare & Hallowicked | def. | Brodie Lee & Grizzly Redwood | | |
CHIKARA matches wrestled by Frightmare during 2009