| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 IWA-MS Medora Mayhem
Aug 30th 2008 | Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy | def. | Davey Vega & Gary Jay | | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '09: Night 2
Mar 28th 2009 | Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy | def. | Davey Vega & Gary the Barn Owl | | |
IWA-MS Wrestling With a Heart 2
Dec 4th 2009 | Devin Cutter & Mason Cutter | def. | Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy | | |
IWA-MS Winter Wars 2010
Jan 2nd 2010 | Bucky Collins & Ryan Phoenix | def. | Devin Cutter & Mason Cutter, Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy | three-way tag | |
Beyond Wrestletopia
Mar 27th 2010 | Aiden Hallows & Alexandre Rudolph & Evan Gelistico | def. | Jarek 1:20 & Mat Fitchett & Steve Scott | 6-person tag | |
AIW Jack of All Trios - Night 1
Apr 9th 2010 | John Thorne & Nick Belushi & The Duke | def. | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | 6-person tag | |
AIW Jack of All Trios - Night 2
Apr 10th 2010 | Dave Manzo & Tommy Treznik | def. | Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy | dark
| |
AIW From Dusk Til Dawn
Jun 4th 2010 | Nick Belushi & The Duke | def. | Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy | | |
AAW Massacre on 26th Street 2010
Oct 22nd 2010 | Evan Gelistico & Johnny Wisdom | def. | Davey Vega & Pierre Abernathy | dark
| |
F1RST The Return: 2011
Jul 8th 2011 | Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy | def. | Udo & Venom | | |
Beyond About Time
Jul 23rd 2011 | Davey Vega & Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. | Chase Burnett & Corvis Fear & Johnny Cockstrong & Zane Silver | Captain Falls Elimination Tag | |
Beyond Back in Flesh
Oct 2nd 2011 | Aaron Epic & Pinkie Sanchez & Sugar Dunkerton | def. | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | 6-person tag | |
AIW Nightmare Before X-Mas 5
Dec 23rd 2011 | ACH & Davey Vega & Mat Fitchett | def. | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | 6-person tag | |
AIW Gauntlet For the Gold 7
Mar 2nd 2012 | Joey the Snake & K. Fernandez & Luis Diamante | def. | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | 6-person tag | |
AIW Straight Outta Compton
Apr 6th 2012 | Davey Vega & Mat Fitchett | def. | Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy | | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2012 - Day 1
May 11th 2012 | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. | Jack Verville & K. J. Crush & Maserati Rick | dark
6-person tag | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2012 - Day 2
May 12th 2012 | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. | Joey Diamante & K. Fernandez & Luis Diamante | dark
6-person tag | |
Beyond/SLA Double Trouble
Jun 16th 2012 | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. | Arik Cannon & Christian Rose & Darin Corbin | 6-person tag | |
Beyond Swamp Sessions: Live Event
Jul 27th 2012 | Bill Carr & Dan Barry & Johnny Cockstrong & Ken Scampi | def. | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy & R.D. Evans | Captain Falls Elimination Tag | |
Beyond Swamp Sessions: Studio Taping - Day 2
Jul 29th 2012 | Aaron Epic & Sugar Dunkerton | def. | Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy | | |
AIW Point Break
Sep 23rd 2012 | Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy | def. | Jock Samson | handicap tag | |
AIW Hell on Earth 8
Nov 23rd 2012 | Evan Gelistico & Pierre Abernathy | def. | Jock Samson & Marion Fontaine | | |
AIW The End of the World
Dec 21st 2012 | Colt Cabana & Jock Samson & Marion Fontaine | def. | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | 6-person tag | |
AIW Conspiracy Theory
Feb 9th 2013 | Bill Carr & Dr. Colonel Nolan Angus & Jock Samson | def. | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | 6-person tag | |
AIW Gauntlet For the Gold 8
Mar 29th 2013 | Colin Delaney | def. | ACH, Addy Starr, Allysin Kay, B.J. Whitmer, Bobby Beverly, Chris Dickinson, Dios Salvador, Ethan Page, Evan Gelistico, Gary Jay, Gregory Iron, Jack Verville, Jake Clemons, Jock Samson, Johnny Gargano, Josh Alexander, Josh Prohibition, Kodama, Louis Lyndon, Marion Fontaine, Matt Cross, Obariyon, Pierre Abernathy, Rickey Shane Page, Russ Myers, Super Oprah, T-Money, Tim Donst, Veda Scott | Battle Royal | |
Evan Gelistico