| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 NXT TV Taping #179
Jan 7th 2016 | Carmella | def. (pin) | Emma | | |
NXT TV Taping #176
Jan 7th 2016 | Carmella | def. | Alexa Bliss, Aliyah, Asuka, Billie Kay, Cameron, Deonna Purrazzo, Emma, Eva Marie, Liv Morgan, Peyton Royce | Battle Royal | |
NXT TV Taping #177
Jan 7th 2016 | Bayley & Carmella | def. (sub) | Alexa Bliss & Emma | | |
NXT Citrus Springs Show
Jan 9th 2016 | Billie Kay & Emma & Eva Marie | def. (pin) | Adrienne Reese & Carmella & Liv Morgan | 6-person tag | |
NXT Milwaukee Show
Jan 14th 2016 | Carmella | def. (pin) | Alexa Bliss | | |
NXT Green Bay Show
Jan 15th 2016 | Eva Marie & Nia Jax | def. (pin) | Carmella & Peyton Royce | | |
NXT Chicago Show - Afternoon
Jan 16th 2016 | Carmella | def. (sub) | Alexa Bliss | | |
NXT Chicago Show - Noon
Jan 16th 2016 | Eva Marie & Nia Jax | def. (pin) | Carmella & Peyton Royce | | |
NXT TV Taping #182
Jan 22nd 2016 | Eva Marie & Nia Jax | def. (pin) | Bayley & Carmella | | |
NXT TV Taping #180
Jan 22nd 2016 | Bayley (c) | def. (pin) | Carmella | | NXT Women's Title
|
NXT Pittsburgh Show
Jan 29th 2016 | Nia Jax | def. (pin) | Carmella | | |
NXT Detroit Show
Jan 30th 2016 | Carmella | def. | Alexa Bliss | | |
NXT Tampa Show
Feb 12th 2016 | Carmella & Colin Cassady & Enzo Amore | def. | Alexa Bliss & Blake & Murphy | 6-person tag | |
NXT Palatka Show
Feb 13th 2016 | Carmella | def. | Peyton Royce | | |
NXT Philadelphia Show
Feb 18th 2016 | Carmella | def. (sub) | Peyton Royce | | |
NXT Asbury Park Show
Feb 19th 2016 | Carmella | def. | Peyton Royce | | |
NXT Albany Show
Feb 20th 2016 | Carmella | def. | Peyton Royce | | |
NXT Citrus Springs Show
Mar 4th 2016 | Carmella | def. | Daria Berenato | | |
NXT Bartow Show
Mar 5th 2016 | Carmella | def. | Daria Berenato | | |
NXT Coral Gables Show
Mar 17th 2016 | Aliyah & Carmella | def. | Billie Kay & Emma | | |
NXT Palm Beach Show
Mar 18th 2016 | Bayley & Carmella | def. | Billie Kay & Emma | | |
NXT Wauchula Show
Mar 19th 2016 | Nia Jax | def. (pin) | Carmella | | |
NXT Largo Show
Mar 24th 2016 | Carmella & Liv Morgan | def. (sub) | Billie Kay & Emma | | |
NXT Venice Show
Mar 25th 2016 | Carmella | def. | Emma | | |
NXT TV Taping #191
Apr 2nd 2016 | Carmella | def. (sub) | Aliyah | | |
NXT Concord Show
Apr 7th 2016 | Eva Marie | def. | Carmella | | |
NXT Columbia Show
Apr 8th 2016 | Carmella | def. (sub) | Peyton Royce | | |
NXT North Charleston Show
Apr 9th 2016 | Eva Marie | def. | Carmella | | |
NXT Lowell Show
Apr 21st 2016 | Bayley & Carmella | def. (pin) | Dana Brooke & Peyton Royce | | |
NXT Rhode Island Show
Apr 22nd 2016 | Bayley & Carmella | def. | Alexa Bliss & Dana Brooke | | |
NXT Poughkeepsie Show
Apr 23rd 2016 | Bayley & Carmella | def. (pin) | Dana Brooke & Peyton Royce | | |
NXT TV Taping #194
Apr 28th 2016 | Carmella | def. (sub) | Peyton Royce | | |
NXT Cocoa Beach Show
Apr 30th 2016 | Carmella | def. | Aliyah | | |
NXT Citrus Springs Show
May 6th 2016 | Aliyah & Carmella | def. (sub) | Mandy Rose & Peyton Royce | | |
NXT Bartow Show
May 12th 2016 | Carmella | def. | Peyton Royce | | |
NXT Largo Show
May 13th 2016 | Carmella & Daria Berenato | def. | Lana & Mandy Rose | | |
NXT Jacksonville Show
May 14th 2016 | Carmella & Daria Berenato | def. | Mandy Rose & Peyton Royce | | |
NXT TV Taping #195
May 19th 2016 | Nia Jax | def. (pin) | Alexa Bliss, Carmella | three-way | |
NXT Venice Show
May 20th 2016 | Asuka & Carmella | def. (sub) | Nia Jax & Peyton Royce | | |
NXT Evansville Show
Jun 2nd 2016 | Carmella | def. | Peyton Royce | | |
NXT Nashville Show
Jun 3rd 2016 | Bayley & Carmella | def. (pin) | Daria & Peyton Royce | | |
NXT Atlanta Show
Jun 4th 2016 | Carmella | def. (sub) | Peyton Royce | | |
NXT TV Taping #199
Jun 9th 2016 | Alexa Bliss | def. (pin) | Carmella | | |
NXT TV Taping #197
Jun 9th 2016 | Carmella | def. (sub) | Tessa Blanchard | | |
 NXT Download Festival - Day 2 - 2nd Session
Jun 11th 2016 | Bayley & Carmella | def. | Nia Jax & Nicola Glencross | | |
NXT Download Festival - Day 2 - 1st session
Jun 11th 2016 | Carmella | def. (pin) | Nicola Glencross | | |
NXT Download Festival - Day 3
Jun 12th 2016 | Asuka (c) | def. | Carmella | | NXT Women's Title
|
NXT Belfast Show
Jun 13th 2016 | Bayley & Carmella | def. (pin) | Nikki Storm & Peyton Royce | | |
 NXT Dublin Show
Jun 14th 2016 | Bayley & Carmella | def. | Alexa Bliss & Nia Jax | | |
NXT Liverpool Show
Jun 15th 2016 | Bayley & Carmella | def. | Nicola Glencross & Peyton Royce | | |
Carmella during 2016