| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AEW Dynamite #26 Taping
Mar 26th 2020 | Hikaru Shida | def. (pin) | Anna Jayy | | |
AEW Dark #30 (airdate)
Apr 21st 2020 | Penelope Ford | def. (pin) | Anna Jay | | |
AEW Dynamite #37 Taping
Jun 11th 2020 | Abadon | def. (pin) | Anna Jay | | |
AEW Women's Tag Team Cup Tournament: Deadly Draw - Night 1 Taping
Jul 29th 2020 | Anna Jay & Tay Conti | def. (pin) | Ariane Andrew & Nyla Rose | | |
AEW Women's Tag Team Cup Tournament: Deadly Draw - Night 3 Taping
Aug 12th 2020 | Diamante & Ivelisse | def. (pin) | Anna Jay & Tay Conti | | |
AEW Dark #49 Taping
Aug 27th 2020 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Red Velvet | | |
AEW Dark #51 Taping
Sep 5th 2020 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Skyler Moore | | |
AEW Late Night Dynamite Taping
Sep 16th 2020 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Brandi Rhodes | | |
AEW Dark #58 Taping
Oct 21st 2020 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Katalina Perez | | |
AEW Dynamite #60 Taping
Nov 19th 2020 | Hikaru Shida (c) | def. (pin) | Anna Jay | | AEW Women's Championship
|
AEW Dark #66 Taping
Dec 3rd 2020 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Dani Jordyn | | |
AEW Dark #68 Taping
Dec 23rd 2020 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Jazmin Allure | | |
AEW Dynamite #65 - Brodie Lee: Celebration of Life
Dec 30th 2020 | Anna Jay & Tay Conti | def. (sub) | Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. & Penelope Ford | | |
AEW Dark #70 Taping
Jan 6th 2021 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Alex Gracia | | |
AEW All Out 2021
Sep 5th 2021 | Ruby Soho | def. | Abadon, Anna Jay, Big Swole, Diamante, Emi Sakura, Hikaru Shida, Jade Cargill, Jamie Hayter, Kiera Hogan, KiLynn King, Leyla Hirsch, Nyla Rose, Penelope Ford, Rebel (not Reba), Red Velvet, Riho, Skye Blue, Tay Conti, The Bunny, Thunder Rosa | Casino Battle Royale | |
AEW Dark: Elevation #28 Taping
Sep 8th 2021 | Anna Jay & Tay Conti | def. (sub) | Ella Shae & Jaylee | | |
AEW Dark #108 Taping
Sep 11th 2021 | Anna Jay | def. (sub) | Ashley D'Amboise | | |
AEW Rampage #6 Taping
Sep 15th 2021 | Anna Jay | def. (pin) | The Bunny | | |
AEW Rampage #7 - Grand Slam Taping
Sep 22nd 2021 | Penelope Ford | def. (pin) | Anna Jay | | |
AEW Dynamite #104
Sep 29th 2021 | Anna Jay & Tay Conti | def. (sub) | Penelope Ford & The Bunny | | |
AEW Rampage #11 Taping
Oct 16th 2021 | Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. | def. | Anna Jay | grudge match | !BANG! TV World Heavyweight Title
|
 Jericho Cruise Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea: Triple Whammy - Day 3
Oct 23rd 2021 | Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. & Jamie Hayter | def. | Anna Jay & Kris Statlander | | |
Jericho Cruise Chris Jericho's Rock N Wrestling Rager At Sea: Triple Whammy - Day 4
Oct 24th 2021 | Abadon & Anna Jay & Kris Statlander | def. | Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. & Jamie Hayter & Rebel | 6-person tag | |
AEW Dynamite #109
Nov 3rd 2021 | Jamie Hayter | def. (pin) | Anna Jay | | |
AEW Dynamite #110
Nov 10th 2021 | Anna Jay & Tay Conti & Thunder Rosa | def. (pin) | Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. & Jamie Hayter & Rebel (not Reba) | 6-person tag | |
Anna Jay