Buddy Matthews
Profile & Match Listing • Facts & Stats • PWI Ratings • Opponents & Partners • Win/Loss Record • Star Ratings • Win Types • Relations • PPVIntroduction
Below you can see all known star ratings for wrestling matches featuring in Dave Meltzer's Wrestling Observer Newsletter. Please note that ratings are given to the overall match; not to the performers within them. Therefore, high or low ratings may reflect aspects of the match including booking, length and performance of partners/opponents, over which the performers may have little or no control. Please also note that a match that received a particular rating many years ago may have been judged on a different criteria from today's.Following the same rating system devised in part by Jim Cornette, matches are rated from the lowest rating of -***** (-5) through to the highest rating of ***** (+5), with a small number of matches being rated above that theoretical maximum. Matches with a rating of zero stars are referred to as a "DUD" and an average match tends to score around a ** (2) rating. All ratings can only be considered subjective and this page is designed purely for reference purposes.
Buddy Matthews
Promotion Search: All • AEW • NJPW • NXT • WWE Year Search: All • 2013 • 2014 • 2015 • 2016 • 2017 • 2018 • 2019 • 2020 • 2021 • 2022
Matches Shown: 1 to 50 of 57 (first • prev • next • last) ... Results per page: 10 • 25 • 50 • 100 • 250 • All ... Sort: newest first • oldest first ... Title Matches: Click to View
| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) | Rating | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 AEW Grand Slam AustraliaFeb 15th 2025 | Kazuchika Okada (c) | def. (pin) | Buddy Matthews | AEW Continental Championship | **** (4.00) | |
 AEW Dynamite #279Feb 5th 2025 | Konosuke Takeshita & Kyle Fletcher | def. (pin) | Brody King & Buddy Matthews | ****½ (4.5) | ||
| AEW Dynamite #275 Jan 8th 2025 | Will Ospreay | def. (pin) | Buddy Matthews | ****½ (4.5) | ||
| AEW Collision #60 Aug 31st 2024 | Buddy Matthews | def. (pin) | Komander | ***¾ (3.75) | ||
 AEW All In London 2024Aug 25th 2024 | Claudio Castagnoli & PAC & Wheeler YUTA | def. | Austin Gunn & Colten Gunn & Juice Robinson & Brody King & Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black & Christian Cage (c) & Killswitch (c) & Nick Wayne (c) | Ladder (4-way trios tag) | AEW World Trios Titles (title change) | ****½ (4.5) |
| AEW Collision #57 Aug 10th 2024 | Austin Gunn & Colten Gunn & Juice Robinson | draw (DCO) | Brody King & Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black | referee: Christian Cage 6-person tag | ***¾ (3.75) | |
| AEW Dynasty Apr 21st 2024 | Brody King & Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black | def. (pin) | Adam Copeland & Eddie Kingston & Mark Briscoe | 6-person tag | ****¼ (4.25) | |
| AEW Collision #41 Apr 13th 2024 | Brody King & Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black | def. (pin) | Action Andretti & Dante Martin & Matt Sydal | 6-person tag | ***¾ (3.75) | |
| AEW Collision #37 Taping Mar 7th 2024 | Brody King & Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black | def. (pin) | Jay Lethal & Jeff Jarrett & Mark Briscoe | street fight (6-man tag) | **** (4.00) | |
| AEW Collision #32 Jan 27th 2024 | Cash Wheeler & Daniel Garcia & Dax Harwood | def. | Brody King & Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black | steel cage (3 on 3) | ****½ (4.5) | |
| AEW Collision #31 Jan 20th 2024 | Daniel Garcia | def. (pin) | Buddy Matthews | **** (4.00) | ||
| AEW Collision #29 Jan 6th 2024 | Cash Wheeler & Dax Harwood | def. (pin) | Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black | ****½ (4.5) | ||
| AEW All In: London Aug 27th 2023 | Anthony Bowens & Billy Gunn & Max Caster | def. (pin) | Brody King (c) & Buddy Matthews (c) & Malakai Black (c) | Open House Rules (6-person tag) | AEW World Trios Titles (title change) | **½ (2.5) |
| AEW Collision #9 Aug 12th 2023 | Brody King (c) & Buddy Matthews (c) & Malakai Black (c) | def. (pin) | Cash Wheeler & CM Punk & Dax Harwood | 6-person tag | AEW World Trios Titles | ***¾ (3.75) |
| AEW Collision #7 Jul 29th 2023 | Andrade El Idolo | def. | Buddy Matthews | ladder | **** (4.00) | |
| AEW Collision #1 Jun 17th 2023 | Andrade El Idolo | def. (sub) | Buddy Matthews | **** (4.00) | ||
| AEW Double Or Nothing 2023 May 28th 2023 | Brody King (c) & Buddy Matthews (c) & Malakai Black (c) | def. (pin) | Anthony Bowens & Daddy Ass & Max Caster | Open House Rules (6-person tag) | AEW World Trios Titles | ***¼ (3.25) |
| AEW Dynamite #184 Apr 12th 2023 | Orange Cassidy (c) | def. (pin) | Buddy Matthews | AEW International Championship | ***¾ (3.75) | |
| AEW Dynamite #183 Apr 5th 2023 | Brody King (c) & Buddy Matthews (c) & Malakai Black (c) | def. (pin) | Chuck Taylor & Orange Cassidy & Trent Beretta | 6-person tag | AEW World Trios Titles | ***½ (3.5) |
 AEW Dynamite #180Mar 15th 2023 | Brody King (c) & Buddy Matthews (c) & Malakai Black (c) | def. (pin) | Chris Jericho & Daniel Garcia & Sammy Guevara, Kenny Omega & Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | three-way tag | AEW World Trios Titles | ****½ (4.5) |
| AEW Revolution 2023 Mar 5th 2023 | Brody King & Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black | def. (pin) | Kenny Omega (c) & Matt Jackson (c) & Nick Jackson (c) | 6-person tag | AEW World Trios Titles (title change) | ****¾ (4.75) |
| AEW Dynamite #173 Jan 25th 2023 | Darby Allin (c) | def. (pin) | Buddy Matthews | AEW TNT Championship | ***¾ (3.75) | |
| AEW All Out 2022 Sep 4th 2022 | Darby Allin & Miro & Sting | def. (pin) | Brody King & Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black | 6-person tag | ***¼ (3.25) | |
| AEW Dynamite #140 Jun 8th 2022 | PAC | def. (pin) | Buddy Matthews | ***½ (3.5) | ||
| AEW Double Or Nothing 2022 May 29th 2022 | Brody King & Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black | def. (pin) | PAC & Penta Oscuro & Rey Fenix | 6-person tag | ****½ (4.5) | |
| AEW Revolution 2022 Mar 6th 2022 | Brody King & Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black | def. (pin) | Erick Redbeard & PAC & Penta Oscuro | 6-person tag | ****¼ (4.25) | |
| NJPW Battle In The Valley Nov 13th 2021 | Kazuchika Okada | def. (pin) | Buddy Matthews | ***¾ (3.75) | ||
| WWE Survivor Series '20 Nov 22nd 2020 | The Miz | def. | Angel Garza, Apollo Crews, Cedric Alexander, Chad Gable, Dolph Ziggler, Dominik Mysterio, Elias, Humberto Carrillo, Jeff Hardy, John Morrison, Kalisto, Murphy, Rey Mysterio, Ricochet, Robert Roode, Shelton Benjamin, Shinsuke Nakamura | dark Battle Royal | **¼ (2.25) | |
| WWE Friday Night Smackdown Oct 23rd 2020 | Seth Rollins | def. (pin) | Murphy | ***¾ (3.75) | ||
| WWE The Horror Show at Extreme Rules - Part 1 Jul 19th 2020 | Kevin Owens | def. (pin) | Murphy | ***¼ (3.25) | ||
| WWE Elimination Chamber '20 Mar 8th 2020 | Angelo Dawkins (c) & Montez Ford (c) | def. (pin) | Murphy & Seth Rollins | WWE Raw Tag Team Championship | *** (3.00) | |
 WWE Super Showdown 2020Feb 27th 2020 | Murphy (c) & Seth Rollins (c) | def. (pin) | Angelo Dawkins & Montez Ford | WWE Raw Tag Team Championship | **¾ (2.75) | |
| WWE Monday Night Raw Dec 30th 2019 | Aleister Black | def. (pin) | Buddy Murphy | **** (4.00) | ||
| WWE TLC: Tables, Ladders and Chairs '19 Dec 15th 2019 | Aleister Black | def. (pin) | Buddy Murphy | ***½ (3.5) | ||
| WWE Crown Jewel 2019 Oct 31st 2019 | Humberto Carrillo | def. | Akira Tozawa, Andrade, Apollo Crews, Buddy Murphy, Cedric Alexander, Drake Maverick, Eric Young, Erick Rowan, Heath Slater, Luke Harper, Mojo Rawley, No Way Jose, R-Truth, Shelton Benjamin, Sin Cara (II), Sunil Singh, The Brian Kendrick, Titus O'Neil, Tony Nese | Battle Royal | *¾ (1.75) | |
| WWE Smackdown Live Aug 20th 2019 | Buddy Murphy | def. (pin) | Daniel Bryan | ***¾ (3.75) | ||
| WWE Smackdown Live Aug 13th 2019 | Roman Reigns | def. (pin) | Buddy Murphy | **** (4.00) | ||
| WWE SummerSlam '19 Aug 11th 2019 | Buddy Murphy | def. (DQ) | Apollo Crews | *¾ (1.75) | ||
| WWE Super Showdown 2019 Jun 7th 2019 | Mansoor | def. | Akam, Akira Tozawa, Ali, Apollo Crews, Bo Dallas, Brian Kendrick, Buddy Murphy, Cedric Alexander, Cesaro, Chad Gable, Curt Hawkins, Curtis Axel, Dash Wilder, Drew Gulak, EC3, Elias, Eric Young, Erik, Heath Slater, Humberto Carrillo, Ivar, Jey Uso, Jimmy Uso, Jinder Mahal, Karl Anderson, Luke Gallows, Matt Hardy, Mike Kanellis, Mojo Rawley, No Way Jose, Oney Lorcan, Otis, Rezar, Ricochet, Robert Roode, Rowan, Rusev, Samir Singh, Samoa Joe, Scott Dawson, Shelton Benjamin, Shinsuke Nakamura, Sin Cara (II), Sunil Singh, The Miz, Titus O'Neil, Tony Nese, Tucker, Xavier Woods, Zack Ryder | Battle Royal | ** (2.00) | |
| WWE WrestleMania 35 Apr 7th 2019 | Tony Nese | def. (pin) | Buddy Murphy (c) | dark | WWE Cruiserweight Title (title change) | ***½ (3.5) |
| WWE Elimination Chamber '19 Feb 17th 2019 | Buddy Murphy (c) | def. (pin) | Akira Tozawa | dark | WWE Cruiserweight Title | **** (4.00) |
| WWE Royal Rumble '19 Jan 27th 2019 | Buddy Murphy (c) | def. (pin) | Akira Tozawa, Hideo Itami, Kalisto | dark fatal 4-way | WWE Cruiserweight Title | **** (4.00) |
| WWE TLC: Tables, Ladders and Chairs '18 Dec 16th 2018 | Buddy Murphy (c) | def. (pin) | Cedric Alexander | dark | WWE Cruiserweight Title | ***½ (3.5) |
| WWE Survivor Series '18 Nov 18th 2018 | Buddy Murphy (c) | def. (pin) | Mustafa Ali | WWE Cruiserweight Title | **** (4.00) | |
| WWE Super Show-Down Oct 6th 2018 | Buddy Murphy | def. (pin) | Cedric Alexander (c) | WWE Cruiserweight Title (title change) | ****¼ (4.25) | |
| WWE 205 Live #92 Aug 28th 2018 | Buddy Murphy | def. (pin) | Kalisto | ****¼ (4.25) | ||
| WWE 205 Live #91 Aug 21st 2018 | Gran Metalik & Lince Dorado | def. (pin) | Buddy Murphy & Tony Nese | **** (4.00) | ||
| WWE 205 Live #84 Jul 3rd 2018 | Mustafa Ali | def. (pin) | Buddy Murphy | no disqualification | ****½ (4.5) | |
| WWE 205 Live #79 May 29th 2018 | Cedric Alexander (c) | def. (pin) | Buddy Murphy | WWE Cruiserweight Title | ****¼ (4.25) | |
| WWE 205 Live #76 May 8th 2018 | Buddy Murphy | def. (pin) | Mustafa Ali | **** (4.00) | ||
- this page (http://www.profightdb.com/wrestler-star-ratings/buddy-matthews-9734.html)
- the Internet Wrestling Database homepage (www.profightdb.com)