| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 N/A The Wrestling Showcase
Sep 3rd 2022 | Matt Cardona | def. (pin) | Tatanka | | |
FWF Live! 2
Nov 25th 2021 | Brian Myers | def. | Tatanka | | |
Heroes & Legends X
Apr 21st 2018 | Kongo Kong (c) | def. | Tatanka | | HLW Championship
|
Legends of Wrestling Augusta Show
Mar 25th 2017 | Tatanka | def. (pin) | Wes Brisco | | |
WWE WrestleMania 32
Apr 3rd 2016 | Baron Corbin | def. | Adam Rose, Bo Dallas, Curtis Axel, Damien Sandow, Darren Young, Diamond Dallas Page, Fandango, Goldust, Heath Slater, Jack Swagger, Kane, Konnor, Mark Henry, R-Truth, Shaquille O'Neal, Tatanka, The Big Show, Tyler Breeze, Viktor | Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal | |
Heroes & Legends VI
Mar 26th 2016 | Tatanka | def. | Kongo Kong | | |
JCW (NJ) Tatanka vs. Dickinson II
Dec 6th 2014 | Chris Dickinson | def. | Tatanka | | |
JCW (NJ) Howell Show
Nov 21st 2014 | Tatanka | def. | Chris Dickinson | | |
WCPBTW Live In Chillicothe
Oct 11th 2014 | Tatanka | def. | Kyron | | |
Legends of Wrestling Youngstown Show
Nov 3rd 2013 | Tatanka | def. | Jon Bolen | | |
Heroes & Legends II
Aug 30th 2013 | Tatanka | def. (DQ) | Dru Skillz (c) | | HLW Championship
|
Heroes & Legends I
Mar 23rd 2013 | Dru Skillz (c) | def. | Tatanka | | HLW Championship
|
CHIKARA King of Trios '12 - Day 2
Sep 15th 2012 | Tatanka | def. | Sugar Dunkerton | | |
CHIKARA King of Trios '12 - Day 1
Sep 14th 2012 | 2 Cold Scorpio & Jerry Lynn & Tommy Dreamer | def. | Aldo Montoya & Tatanka & The 1-2-3 Kid | 6-person tag | |
PWG Kurt Russellreunion 2: The Reunioning
Jan 29th 2011 | Roddy Piper | def. | Barry Orton, Bob Orton Jr., Chavo Guerrero Sr., Cruel Connection I, Danny Davis, Jimmy Hart, Mando Guerrero, Mike Graham, Rock Riddle, Savio Vega, Sean Morley, Shane Douglas, Tatanka, Terry Funk, The Barbarian, The Warlord, Tito Santana, Vampiro | Battle Royal | |
LL USA Masked Warriors #8
Dec 12th 2010 | Blue Demon, Jr. | def. | Tatanka | dark
| |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Dec 8th 2009 | Tatanka | def. | Jay Lethal | | |
 AWR Halloween Revenge Tour '08 - Day 8
Nov 11th 2008 | Tatanka | def. | Joe E. Legend | | |
AWR Halloween Revenge Tour '08 - Day 7
Nov 10th 2008 | Tatanka | def. | Joe E. Legend | | |
AWR Halloween Revenge Tour '08 - Day 6
Nov 9th 2008 | Tatanka | def. | Joe E. Legend | | |
AWR Halloween Revenge Tour '08 - Day 5
Nov 8th 2008 | Tatanka | def. | Joe E. Legend | | |
AWR Halloween Revenge Tour '08 - Day 4
Nov 6th 2008 | Tatanka | def. | Joe E. Legend | | |
AWR Halloween Revenge Tour '08 - Day 3
Nov 5th 2008 | Joe E. Legend | def. | Tatanka | | |
AWR Halloween Revenge Tour '08 - Day 2
Nov 4th 2008 | Tatanka | def. | Joe E. Legend | | |
 AWR Halloween Revenge Tour '08 - Day 1
Oct 26th 2008 | Tatanka | def. | Cannonball Grizzly | | |
Tatanka