| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 NXT TV Taping #104
Jun 12th 2014 | C. J. Parker | def. (pin) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT TV Taping #108
Jul 17th 2014 | Konnor & Viktor | def. | Mac Miles & Steve Cutler | | |
NXT TV Taping #111
Jul 31st 2014 | Mojo Rawley | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Cocoa Show
Aug 8th 2014 | Baron Corbin | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Largo Show
Aug 21st 2014 | Baron Corbin | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Aug 23rd 2014 | Steve Cutler | def. | Sawyer Fulton | | |
NXT Jacksonville Show
Oct 2nd 2014 | Baron Corbin | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Cocoa Beach Show
Oct 3rd 2014 | Baron Corbin | def. (pin) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Oct 4th 2014 | Baron Corbin | def. (pin) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT TV Taping #123
Oct 23rd 2014 | Bull Dempsey | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT TV Taping #125
Oct 23rd 2014 | Baron Corbin | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Jacksonville Show
Oct 24th 2014 | Tye Dillinger | def. (pin) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Daytona Beach Show
Nov 8th 2014 | Angelo Dawkins & Chad Gable & Sawyer Fulton | def. (pin) | Elias Samson & Hugo Knox & Steve Cutler | 6-person tag | |
NXT Orlando Show
Nov 13th 2014 | Elias Samson & Hugo Knox & Steve Cutler | def. (pin) | Angelo Dawkins & Chad Gable & Sawyer Fulton | 6-person tag | |
NXT Largo Show
Nov 14th 2014 | Elias Samson & Hugo Knox & Steve Cutler | def. (pin) | Angelo Dawkins & Chad Gable & Sawyer Fulton | 6-person tag | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Nov 15th 2014 | Elias Samson & Hugo Knox & Steve Cutler | def. (pin) | Angelo Dawkins & Chad Gable & Sawyer Fulton | 6-person tag | |
NXT Cocoa Beach Show
Nov 21st 2014 | Marcus Louis | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT TakeOver: R Evolution
Dec 11th 2014 | Bull Dempsey | def. (pin) | Steve Cutler | dark
| |
NXT TV Taping #142
Feb 18th 2015 | Baron Corbin | def. (pin) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Bartow Show
Mar 13th 2015 | Baron Corbin | def. (pin) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Citrus Springs Show
Mar 14th 2015 | Mike Rawlis | def. (pin) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Orlando Show
Apr 4th 2015 | Scott Dawson | def. | Aiden English, Angelo Dawkins, Baron Corbin, Bull Dempsey, Colin Cassady, Dash Wilder, Digg Rawlis, Elias Samson, Enzo Amore, Josh Woods, Marcus Louis, Noah Pang-Potjes, Sabby Piscitelli, Sawyer Fulton, Simon Gotch, Steve Cutler, Sunny Dhinsa, Tye Dillinger, Tyler Breeze | Battle Royal | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Apr 11th 2015 | Steve Cutler | def. | Chad Gable | | |
NXT Lakeland Show
Apr 30th 2015 | Elias Samson | draw (NC) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Cocoa Beach Show
May 2nd 2015 | Elias Samson | draw (NC) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Jacksonville Show
May 7th 2015 | Braun Stowman | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Largo Show
May 8th 2015 | Marcus Louis | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Orlando Show
May 9th 2015 | Elias Samson | def. (DQ) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT TV Taping #154
Jun 18th 2015 | Chad Gable & Jason Jordan | def. | Elias Samson & Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Jacksonville Show
Jul 11th 2015 | Dash Wilder & Mike Rallis & Scott Dawson | def. | Mojo Rawley & Steve Cutler & Zack Ryder | 6-person tag | |
NXT TV Taping #157
Jul 16th 2015 | Baron Corbin | def. (pin) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Venice Show
Jul 18th 2015 | Elias Samson | def. (pin) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Jul 23rd 2015 | Aiden English & Mike Rallis & Simon Gotch & Steve Cutler | def. (pin) | Blake & Dash Wilder & Murphy & Scott Dawson | 8-person tag | |
NXT Tampa Show
Jul 30th 2015 | Tyler Breeze | def. | Aiden English, Angelo Dawkins, Axel Tischer, Bull Dempsey, Cal Bishop, Chad Gable, Dash Wilder, Jason Jordan, Mike Rallis, Preston Cunningham Jr., Sabby Piscitelli, Sawyer Fulton, Scott Dawson, Simon Gotch, Solomon Crowe, Steve Cutler, Tucker Knight, Tye Dillinger, Uhaa Nation | Battle Royal | |
NXT Lakeland Show
Jul 31st 2015 | Uhaa Nation | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Starke Show
Aug 6th 2015 | Steve Cutler | def. | Angelo Dawkins | | |
NXT TV Taping #159
Aug 13th 2015 | Samoa Joe | def. (sub) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Cocoa Beach Show
Aug 28th 2015 | Steve Cutler | def. | Riddick Moss | | |
NXT Gainesville Show
Sep 12th 2015 | Steve Cutler | def. | Alexander Wolfe | | |
NXT Lakeland Show
Sep 24th 2015 | Steve Cutler | def. (pin) | Elias Samson | | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Sep 26th 2015 | Tye Dillinger | def. (pin) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT TV Taping #166
Oct 8th 2015 | Apollo Crews | def. | Baron Corbin, Blake, Bull Dempsey, Colin Cassady, Danny Burch, Dash Wilder, Elias Samson, Enzo Amore, Johnny Gargano, Mojo Rawley, Murphy, Rhyno, Riddick Moss, Samoa Joe, Scott Dawson, Solomon Crowe, Steve Cutler, Tommaso Ciampa, Tye Dillinger, Tyler Breeze, Zack Ryder | Battle Royal | |
NXT Gainesville Show
Oct 30th 2015 | Angelo Dawkins | def. (pin) | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Jacksonville Show
Nov 6th 2015 | Aiden English & Simon Gotch | def. | Steve Cutler & Tino Sabbatelli | | |
NXT Sebring Show
Nov 14th 2015 | Steve Cutler | def. | Noah Kekoa | | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Nov 21st 2015 | Tino Sabbatelli | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Citrus Springs Show
Jan 9th 2016 | Elias Samson | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
NXT Winter Haven Show
Jan 14th 2016 | Steve Cutler | def. | Alex Riley | | |
NXT Cocoa Beach Show
Jan 15th 2016 | Steve Cutler | def. | Alexander Wolfe | | |
NXT Fort Pierce Show
Jan 16th 2016 | Radomir Petkovic | def. | Steve Cutler | | |
Steve Maclin