| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 AIW Forged In Flames
Mar 9th 2007 | Patrick Hayes | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
AIW Forged In Flames
Mar 9th 2007 | John Thorne & Matthew Justice | def. | Nick Belushi & The Duke | | |
AIW Motor City Death Wish
Mar 31st 2007 | Morty Rackem (c) & Rufio Rapier (c) | def. | John Thorne & Matthew Justice, Nick Belushi & The Duke, Facade & Lamont Williams | Fatal Four Way TLC Tag Team Match | AIW Tag Team Championship
|
AIW Driven By Suffering
Apr 20th 2007 | Morty Rackem (c) & Rufio Rapier (c) | def. | Nick Belushi & The Duke, John Thorne & Matthew Justice | three-way tag | AIW Tag Team Championship
|
AIW The Oncoming Storm
Apr 28th 2007 | John Thorne & Matthew Justice | def. | Morty Rackem (c) & Rufio Rapier (c) | Casket (Tag) | AIW Tag Team Championship
(title change) |
AIW Absolution 2
May 20th 2007 | Nick Belushi & The Duke | def. | Morty Rackem & Rufio Rapier & John Thorne (c) & Matthew Justice (c) | Tables, Ladders, and Planks Three-way Tag | AIW Tag Team Championship
(title change) |
AIW Absolute Redemption
Jun 23rd 2007 | John Thorne & Matthew Justice & Shirley Doe | def. | Morty Rackem & Rufio Rapier & Syd Smythe | 6-person tag | |
AIW Tomorrow Never Dies
Sep 30th 2007 | Nick Belushi (c) & Super Oprah | def. | John Thorne & Matthew Justice | | AIW Tag Team Championship
|
AIW Hell on Earth 3
Oct 28th 2007 | Matthew Justice | def. | Hallowicked | | |
AIW Gauntlet for the Gold 3
Feb 24th 2008 | Matt Cross | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
AIW Gauntlet for the Gold 3
Feb 24th 2008 | Sterling James Keenan | def. | Benny Boone, Chris Cronus, Dios Salvador, Dubleve, Eric Ryan, Gregory Iron, Hailey Hatred, Hobo Joe, Jim Roberts, Joey the Snake, John Thorne, Johnny Gargano, Josh Prohibition, K-Fed, Luis Diamante, Mad Man Pondo, Marion Fontaine, Matt Cross, Matt Riot, Matthew Justice, Mike Tolar, Nick Belushi, Rebis, Southside St. Clair, T. J. Dynamite, The Potato, The Savage (Rebis), Thomas Von Erich, Vincent Nothing | Battle Royal | AIW Absolute Championship
|
AIW Destroy Everything!
Mar 21st 2008 | The Thrillbilly & Vincent Nothing | draw (NC) | John Thorne & Matthew Justice | | |
AIW Absolution 3: Guerrilla Warfare
May 25th 2008 | Christian Faith & Mad Man Pondo & Vincent Nothing | def. | Drake Younger & John Thorne & Matthew Justice | Fans Bring the Weapons (3 on 3) | |
AIW Die Another Day
Sep 21st 2008 | Jimmy DeMarco | def. | Facade, Marion Fontaine, Matthew Justice | four-way | |
WWE Monday Night Raw
May 10th 2010 | Dos Caras, Jr. | def. | Matthew Justice | dark
| |
WWE Superstars Taping #2
May 11th 2010 | Curt Hawkins & Vance Archer | def. | James White & Matthew Busch | | |
AIW AIW at The Rockstar Energy Mayhem Festival
Jul 21st 2010 | Dave Crist & J-Money & Matthew Justice | def. | Dustin Rayz & Eddie Gonzales & Sid Fabulous | 6-person tag | |
WWE Smackdown! Taping
Jan 25th 2011 | Kofi Kingston | def. | Alberto Del Rio, Kane, Mike Stevens, Seth Allen | "over the top rope" | |
FCW Tampa Show (June '11 #3)
Jun 23rd 2011 | C. J. Parker & Mack Hetfield | def. | Brad Maddox & Peter Orlov | | |
FCW Tampa Show (July '11 #2)
Jul 14th 2011 | Leakee | def. | Mack Hetfield | | |
FCW Summer SlamaRama
Jul 16th 2011 | Leakee & Richie Steamboat | def. | DeSean Bishop & Mack Hetfield | | |
FCW TV Tapings
Jul 21st 2011 | Kevin Hackman | def. | Mack Hetfield | | |
FCW Orlando Show (Jul '11)
Jul 27th 2011 | Richie Steamboat | def. | Mack Hetfield | | |
FCW Tampa Show (July '11 #3)
Jul 28th 2011 | Leakee & Richie Steamboat | def. | Bobby Dutch & Mack Hetfield | | |
FCW Tampa Show (August '11 #2)
Aug 18th 2011 | Audrey Marie & Mike Dalton | def. | Leah West & Mack Hetfield | | |
FCW TV Tapings
Sep 1st 2011 | Mike Dalton | def. (pin) | Mack Hetfield | dark
| |
EVOLVE/NYWC Rocks Off's Cinco De Mayo Festival
Mar 5th 2012 | Apollyon & Rex Lawless & Stockade | def. | Azrieal & Bandido Jr. & Matthew Justice | 6-person tag | |
Beyond Burst the Bubble: Live Event
May 12th 2012 | Corvis Fear & Jonny Mangue | def. | Matthew Justice & Pitboss | referee: Chris Dickinson | |
Beyond/SLA Double Trouble
Jun 16th 2012 | Dany Only & Matthew Justice & Pitboss & Stryknyn | def. | Chase Burnett & Eric Corvis & Jonny Mangue & Zane Silver | 8-person tag | |
IWC Super Indy XI
Jun 23rd 2012 | Gory | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Sep 22nd 2012 | Ryan McBride & Veda Scott | def. | Marti Belle & Matt Justice | dark
| |
Beyond All Aboard
Oct 13th 2012 | Jaka | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
House of Hardcore XIX
Oct 14th 2016 | Bill Carr & Dan Barry & Swoggle | def. | Hale Collins & Matt Justice & Vik Dalishus | 6-person tag | |
AIW Gauntlet for the Gold 12
Mar 24th 2017 | Louis Lyndon | def. | Alex Daniels, Alex Kellar, Bobby Beverly, Brian Carson, Britt Baker, Cheech, Colin Delaney, Dick Justice, DJ Z, Dominic Garrini, Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham, Eddie Kingston, Eric Ryan, Ethan Page, Evan Adams, Facade, Joey Janela, Laredo Kid, Marion Fontaine, Matt Classic, Matthew Justice, Mike Tolar, PB Smooth, Russ Myers, Ryan Kaplan, Shawn Schultz, Steve Pain, T-Money, The Duke | Battle Royal | |
AIW House of the Rising Sun
Apr 8th 2017 | PB Smooth | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
AIW The Next Episode
Apr 21st 2017 | Mike Tolar | def. | Matthew Justice | | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2017 - Day 1
May 26th 2017 | Matthew Justice | def. | Facade | | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2017 - Day 2
May 27th 2017 | Shawn Schultz | def. | Colt Cabana, Matthew Justice, Mordekai | four-way | |
 DWW Invasion
Jun 17th 2017 | John Atlas | def. | Matt Justice | | |
AIW Absolution XII
Jul 21st 2017 | A. J. Gray & Chase Oliver & Garrison King & Joshua Bishop & Tre Lamar | def. | Bobby Beverly & Eric Ryan & Matthew Justice & Russ Myers & T-Money | 10-person tag | |
AIW Cool As Ice
Sep 15th 2017 | Matthew Justice | def. | Maxwell Jacob Friedman | | |
AIW Hell On Earth 13
Nov 24th 2017 | Matthew Justice | def. | Shawn Schultz | | |
AIW Rulers of the World
Dec 29th 2017 | Dick Justice & Ethan Carter III & Matthew Justice | def. | Brian Carson & Dr. Daniel C. Rockingham & Gregory Iron | 6-person tag | |
AIW Death Rowe
Jan 19th 2018 | Matthew Justice | def. | Shane Mercer | | |
AIW We've Got a DilEMMA
Feb 23rd 2018 | Matthew Justice | def. | Calvin Tankman, Louis Lyndon, Tim Donst | four-way | |
AIW Enter the Dragon
Mar 10th 2018 | Matthew Justice | def. | Bobby Beverly, Chase Oliver | three-way | |
AIW Gauntlet for the Gold 13
Mar 23rd 2018 | Nick Gage (c) | def. | Matthew Justice | | AIW Absolute Championship
|
AIW Ain't Nuthin But a Gangsta Party
Apr 20th 2018 | Ethan Page | def. | Matthew Justice | no countout no disqualification | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2018 - Day 1
May 25th 2018 | Matthew Justice | def. | Ethan Page | | |
AIW The J.T. Lightning Invitational Tournament 2018 - Day 2
May 26th 2018 | Matthew Justice | def. (pin) | Gangrel, Magnum CK, Maxwell Jacob Friedman | four-way | |
Matthew Justice