| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 UPW Mat Wars!: Awake
Apr 10th 2004 | Johnny Goodtime & Peter Goodman | def. | Shawn Riddick & Supa Badd | | |
UPW Mat Wars!: Coronation 2
May 15th 2004 | Johnny Goodtime & Peter Goodman | def. | Human Tornado & Sideshow Kjell | | |
UPW Mat Wars!
Jun 12th 2004 | Johnny Goodtime & Peter Goodman | def. | Charles Mercury & Johnny Paradise | | |
UPW Road Wars: Rage For Order
Jul 17th 2004 | Johnny Goodtime & Peter Goodman | def. | Human Tornado & Sideshow Kjell | | |
UPW Meltdown
Jul 20th 2005 | Shawn Riddick & Tommy Wilson | def. | Human Tornado & Lionheart, Johnny Goodtime & Peter Goodman | three-way tag | |
WWE Heat #376 Taping
Oct 31st 2005 | Gregory Helms | def. (sub) | Kevin Martinson | | |
UPW Locked & Loaded
Mar 25th 2006 | Lil Nate (c) | def. | Funky Billy Kim, Human Tornado, Johnny Goodtime, Lionheart, Scorpio Sky | 6-pack challenge | UPW Lightweight Title
|
WWE Monday Night Raw
May 8th 2006 | Umaga | def. (pin) | Kevin Martinson & Tommy Wilson | handicap tag | |
UPW Power Play
May 13th 2006 | Human Tornado & Johnny Goodtime | def. | Quicksilver & Scorpio Sky | | |
NWA Wrestling Showcase TV Tapings
Dec 20th 2008 | Mike DiBiase (c) | def. (pin) | Johnny Goodtime | | NWA North American Heavyweight Title
|
PWG The Secret Of Guerrilla Island
Jun 28th 2009 | Johnny Goodtime | def. | Charles Mercury | | |
PWG Threemendous II - Sixth Anniversary Event
Jul 31st 2009 | Brandon Cutler & Charles Mercury & Dustin Cutler | def. | Brandon Gatson & Jerome Robinson & Johnny Goodtime | 6-person tag | |
PWG Speed of Sound
Aug 28th 2009 | Brandon Cutler & Dustin Cutler | def. | Dustin Cutler & Johnny Goodtime | | |
PWG Guerre Sans Frontières
Sep 4th 2009 | Jerome Robinson & Johnny Goodtime & Shane Haste | def. | Brandon Cutler & Charles Mercury & Dustin Cutler, Malachi Jackson & Phoenix Star & Zokre | three-way nine-person tag | |
PWG Against The Grain
Oct 2nd 2009 | Brandon Gatson | def. | Brandon Cutler, Johnny Goodtime, Malachi Jackson | four-way | |
PWG Battle of Los Angeles '09 - Day 1
Nov 20th 2009 | Roderick Strong | def. | Johnny Goodtime | | |
PWG Battle of Los Angeles '09 - Day 2
Nov 21st 2009 | Colt Cabana & Jerome Robinson & Johnny Goodtime | def. | Austin Aries & Brandon Cutler & Dustin Cutler | 6-person tag | |
PWG Kurt Russellreunion
Jan 30th 2010 | Brandon Cutler & Christina Von Eerie & Dustin Cutler & Ryan Taylor | def. | Candice LeRae & Jerome Robinson & Johnny Goodtime & Malachi Jackson | 8-person tag | |
PWG As The Worm Turns
Feb 27th 2010 | Jerome Robinson & Johnny Goodtime | def. | Malachi Jackson & Ryan Taylor | | |
ROH Phoenix Rising
Mar 27th 2010 | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma & Mike Sydal | def. | David E. Jones & Robert Evans & Ryan Stone | dark
6-person tag | |
PWG Titannica
Apr 10th 2010 | Brandon Cutler & Dustin Cutler | def. | Jerome Robinson & Johnny Goodtime | | |
PWG DDT4 2010
May 9th 2010 | Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | def. | Jerome Robinson & Johnny Goodtime | | |
PWG DIO!
Jun 11th 2010 | Jerome Robinson & Johnny Goodtime | def. | Phoenix Star & Zokre | | |
PWG Seven
Jul 30th 2010 | Brandon Gatson & Candice LeRae & Johnny Goodtime | def. (pin) | Malachi Jackson & Peter Avalon & Ryan Taylor | 6-person tag | |
PWG Battle of Los Angeles '10 - Day 2
Sep 5th 2010 | Brian Cage & Chuck Taylor & Ryan Taylor | def. | Johnny Goodtime & Ricochet & Rocky Romero | 6-person tag | |
PWG The Curse of Guerrilla Island
Oct 9th 2010 | Chuck Taylor | def. | Johnny Goodtime | | |
PWG Cyanide: A Loving Tribute to Poison
Dec 11th 2010 | Brandon Cutler & Dustin Cutler | def. | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | | |
PWG Kurt Russellreunion 2: The Reunioning
Jan 29th 2011 | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | def. | Brandon Cutler & Dustin Cutler, Brian Cage & Ryan Taylor, Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | four corners tag | |
PWG DDT4 2011
Mar 4th 2011 | Davey Richards & Eddie Edwards | def. | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | | |
PWG Card Subject to Change 3
Apr 9th 2011 | Johnny Goodtime | def. | Ryan Taylor | | |
VPW Casino Royale '11
Apr 17th 2011 | Johnny Goodtime | def. (pin) | Jayson Cash | | |
PWG All Star Weekend 8 - Day 1
May 27th 2011 | Matt Jackson (c) & Nick Jackson (c) | def. (pin) | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | | PWG Tag Team Titles
|
PWG All Star Weekend 8 - Day 2
May 28th 2011 | Akira Tozawa & Kevin Steen | def. | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | | |
PWG Eight
Jul 23rd 2011 | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | def. | Joey Ryan & Scorpio Sky | | |
PWG Battle of Los Angeles '11
Aug 20th 2011 | Joey Ryan & Scorpio Sky | def. | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | | |
PWG The Perils of Rock N' Roll Decadence
Sep 10th 2011 | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | def. | Player Dos & Player Uno | | |
PWG Steen Wolf
Oct 22nd 2011 | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | def. | Brian Cage-Taylor & Ryan Taylor | | |
PWG FEAR
Dec 10th 2011 | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | def. (pin) | Adam Cole & Kyle O'Reilly | | |
PWG Kurt Russellreunion 3
Jan 29th 2012 | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | def. (pin) | CIMA & Ricochet | | |
PWG World's Finest
Mar 17th 2012 | Player Uno & Stupefied | def. (pin) | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma, Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | three-way tag | |
PWG DDT4 2012
Apr 21st 2012 | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | def. | Brian Cage-Taylor & Ryan Taylor | | |
PWG DDT4 2012
Apr 21st 2012 | El Generico & Willie Mack | def. | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | | |
PWG Death to All But Metal
May 25th 2012 | Candice LeRae & Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | def. | Joey Ryan & Peter Avalon & Ray Rosas | 6-person tag | |
EWF EWF/AWS United Forces 4
Jul 6th 2012 | Al Katrazz | def. (pin) | Johnny Goodtime (c) | | AWS Heavyweight Championship
(title change) |
PWG Threemendous III
Jul 21st 2012 | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | def. | Chuck Taylor & Ryan Taylor | | |
PWG Failure to Communicate
Oct 27th 2012 | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | def. (pin) | B-Boy & Famous B | | |
PWG Mystery Vortex
Dec 1st 2012 | Player Uno (c) & Stupefied (c) | def. | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | | PWG Tag Team Titles
|
Dragon Gate USA REVOLT! '13
Jan 27th 2013 | Brian Kendrick | def. | B-Boy, Brian Cage, Drake Younger, Famous B, Johnny Goodtime, Johnny Yuma, Ray Rosas | fray | |
PWG All Star Weekend 9 - Night 2
Mar 23rd 2013 | Chuck Taylor & Johnny Gargano | def. (pin) | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | | |
PWG Is Your Body Ready?
Jun 15th 2013 | Brian Cage & Michael Elgin | def. (pin) | Johnny Goodtime & Johnny Yuma | | |
Kevin Martenson