| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 OVW TV Taping #682
Sep 12th 2012 | Sam Shaw | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #683
Sep 19th 2012 | James "Moose" Thomas & Michael Hayes | def. (sub) | Jeremiah Plunkett & Raphael Constantine | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #684
Sep 26th 2012 | Adam Revolver | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #685
Oct 3rd 2012 | Rob Terry | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #686
Oct 10th 2012 | Elvis Pridemoore | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #687
Oct 17th 2012 | Elvis Pridemoore | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | | |
OVW TV Taping #688
Oct 24th 2012 | Adam Revolver & Ryan Howe & Ted McNaler | def. (pin) | Ace Hawkins & Jeremiah Plunkett & Raphael Constantine | dark
6-person tag | |
OVW TV Taping #689
Oct 31st 2012 | Alex Silva & Sam Shaw | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett & Joe Rosa | | |
OVW TV Taping #690
Nov 7th 2012 | Elvis Pridemoore | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #691
Nov 14th 2012 | Jeremiah Plunkett | def. (pin) | Ace Hawkins | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #693
Nov 28th 2012 | Ryan Howe | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #694
Dec 5th 2012 | Jeremiah Plunkett | def. (pin) | Ace Hawkins | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #695
Dec 12th 2012 | Jeremiah Plunkett | def. (pin) | Eddie Diamond | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #698
Dec 19th 2012 | Ryan Howe | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | | |
OVW TV Taping #699
Jan 9th 2013 | Tony Gunn | def. (sub) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #700
Jan 16th 2013 | Randy Royal | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #701
Jan 23rd 2013 | Rudy Switchblade | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #702
Jan 30th 2013 | Joe Rosa | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW Saturday Night Special - Stairway to Hell
Feb 2nd 2013 | Randy Royal | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | | |
OVW TV Taping #703
Feb 6th 2013 | James "Moose" Thomas | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #704
Feb 13th 2013 | Adam Revolver & Ted McNaler | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett & The Bodyguy | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #705
Feb 20th 2013 | Johnny Spade | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #706
Feb 27th 2013 | Jeremiah Plunkett | def. (pin) | Jake Dirden | dark
| |
OVW Saturday Night Special - Do or Die
Mar 2nd 2013 | Elvis Pridemoore & Nick Dumeyer & The Bodyguy | def. (KO) | Albert Einstein Baxter II & Jeremiah Plunkett & Stephon J. Baxter III | 6-person tag | |
OVW TV Taping #707
Mar 6th 2013 | Rob Terry | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #708
Mar 13th 2013 | The Bodyguy | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #709
Mar 20th 2013 | Rockstar Spud (c) | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | | OVW Television Title
|
OVW TV Taping #710
Mar 27th 2013 | Randy Royal | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | dark
| |
OVW TV Taping #712
Apr 9th 2013 | Eddie Diamond & Rob Terry & Ryan Howe | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett & Jessie Godderz & Melvin Maximus | dark
6-person tag | |
Beyond Sleeper Cell Music City
Jul 6th 2014 | Jeremiah Plunkett | def. | Jeremy Flynt | | |
GFW/TNT Show Of Force
Apr 8th 2016 | Shawn Schultz | def. | Alex Taylor, Crazzy Steve, Jeremiah Plunkett | four-way | |
GFW/TNT Road to the Gold
Nov 19th 2016 | Jeff Jarrett | def. | Jeremiah Plunkett & Tony Kozina | handicap tag | |
GFW/TNT The Art of War II
Mar 18th 2017 | Crazzy Steve | def. | Jeremiah Plunkett | | |
GFW/TNT Music City Bowl Players Party
Dec 27th 2017 | Crazzy Steve | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | "hardcore" | |
WrestleCade WrestleCade 2018 - Supershow
Nov 24th 2018 | Fallah Bahh | def. | Axton Ray, Billy Brash, Bobby Fulton, Cam Carter, Chad Skywalker, Chris Hamrick, Dave Dawson, Dylan Fulton, Fred Rosser, Gary Wolfe, George South, Gigolo Justin, Glacier, Hurricane Helms, JB Cole, Jeremiah Plunkett, Keith Mac, LaBron Kozone, Mallaki Matthews, Mark Denny, Mike Camden, Mr. Hughes, Q. T. Marshall, Rex Bacchus, Ricky Roberts, Rob McBride, S.P. the Ghost, Sean Denny, Shane Douglas, Simon Gotch, Stan Lee, The Blue Meanie, The Sandman, Yahya, Zane Dawson, Zane Riley, Zuka King | Battle Royal | |
NWA Pop Up - New Years Clash
Jan 5th 2019 | Maxx Stardom | def. | Jeremiah Plunkett | | |
Impact/TNT Salute To The Troops
Apr 12th 2019 | Rich Swann (c) | def. | Ace Austin, Caleb Konley, Jeremiah Plunkett | four-way | Impact Wrestling X Division Title
|
NWA Powerrr S4E2 Taping
Mar 21st 2021 | Slice Boogie | def. | Jeremiah Plunkett | | |
NWA Powerrr Surge #1 (airdate)
Apr 13th 2021 | Mims | def. | Jeremiah Plunkett | | |
NWA Powerrr S4E8 (airdate)
May 25th 2021 | Trevor Murdoch | def. | Chris Adonis, Crimson, Fred Rosser, Jax Dane, Jeremiah Plunkett, Jordan Clearwater, Marshe Rockett, Matt Cross, Odinson, Parrow, Sal Rinauro, Slice Boogie, Thom Latimer, Tyrus | battle royale | |
NWA When Our Shadows Fall
Jun 6th 2021 | Luke Hawx | def. (pin) | Jeremiah Plunkett | pre-show
| |
NWA Powerrr Surge #4 (airdate)
Jul 13th 2021 | Marshe Rockett | def. | Jeremiah Plunkett | | |
NWA Powerrr S5E8 - The Champions Series Part 3 (airdate)
Aug 3rd 2021 | Jeremiah Plunkett | def. | Colby Corino, Jordan Clearwater, Sal Rinauro | four-way | |
NWA Powerrr S5E10 - The Champions Series Finale (airdate)
Aug 11th 2021 | Chris Adonis & Nick Aldis | def. (sub) | Jeremiah Plunkett & Shawn Daivari | | |
NWA 73 - Wrestling at the Chase
Aug 29th 2021 | Judais | def. | Captain Yuma, El Rudo, Heartthrob Jaden, Jamie Stanley, Jeremiah Plunkett, JTG, Luke Hawx, Marshe Rockett, Mims, Rush Freeman, Sal Rinauro, Slice Boogie | battle royale | |
NWA Powerrr S6E2 Taping
Aug 30th 2021 | Judais | def. | Jeremiah Plunkett | | |
NWA Powerrr S6E3 Taping
Aug 30th 2021 | Jordan Clearwater | def. (pin) | Cyon, Jeremiah Plunkett | triple-threat | |
NWA Powerrr S6E4 Taping
Aug 30th 2021 | The Pope & Trevor Murdoch | def. (pin) | Crimson & Jeremiah Plunkett, Odinson & Parrow | three-way tag | |
NWA Powerrr Surge #6 (airdate)
Oct 20th 2021 | Jeremiah Plunkett | def. | Heartthrob Jaden | | |
NWA Powerrr S6E10 - Season Finale (airdate)
Nov 23rd 2021 | Crimson & Trevor Murdoch | def. (pin) | Jax Dane & Jeremiah Plunkett | | |
Jeremiah Plunkett