| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 FIP Fallout 2014
Sep 5th 2014 | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. (pin) | Jody Kristofferson & Maxwell Chicago & Rhett Giddins | 6-person tag | |
FIP Fallout 2014
Sep 5th 2014 | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. (pin) | Eddie Rios & Jay Cruz & Lince Dorado | 6-person tag | Fallout 2014 Trios Tournament
|
CHIKARA King of Trios '14 - Night 3
Sep 21st 2014 | Davey Vega & Evan Gelistico & Gary the Barn Owl & Pierre Abernathy | def. (pin) | Chuck Taylor & Drew Gulak & Orange Cassidy & The Swamp Monster | 8-person tag | |
IWA-MS What If?
Nov 6th 2014 | Josh Crow | def. | Gary Jay, Jake Parnell, Kaden Sade, Shane Mercer | 5-way ladder | |
IWA-MS November Pain 2014
Nov 20th 2014 | Jimmy Jacobs | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Big Ass Christmas Bash 2014
Dec 11th 2014 | Gary Jay | def. | Corporal Robinson | | |
IWA-MS Revolution Strong Style Tournament 2014
Dec 18th 2014 | Shane Mercer | def. | Gary Jay | strong style battle | |
FIP EVOLVE #36 Kickoff Show
Jan 9th 2015 | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | def. (pin) | Eddie Rios & Jay Cruz & Lince Dorado | 6-person tag | |
FIP Everything Burns '15
Jan 10th 2015 | Lince Dorado | def. (pin) | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Out With the Old, In With the New 2015
Jan 15th 2015 | Breyer Wellington | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Reckon1ng
Jan 22nd 2015 | Gary Jay | def. | The Zodiak | | |
IWA-MS Heartbreak
Feb 12th 2015 | The Zodiak | def. | Chip Day, Dale Patricks, Gary Jay, Gibson Grey, Joe Heiken, Jordan Whittaker, Nick Doepp, Ray Waddell, Sugar Dunkerton | 10-Way | |
FIP Ascension 2015
Feb 20th 2015 | Gary Jay | def. (pin) | Lince Dorado | | |
FIP Ascension 2015
Feb 20th 2015 | Eddie Graves (c) & Teddy Stigma (c) | def. (pin) | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay | | FIP Tag Team Titles
|
IWA-MS Howl at the Moon
Feb 26th 2015 | American Viking | def. | Dale Patricks, Dewey Barnes, Gary Jay, Mikey McFinnegan, Nick Doepp | 6-Way | |
IWA-MS March Massacre 2015
Mar 24th 2015 | American Viking & Frank Wyatt | def. | Gary Jay & Mikey McFinnegan | | |
IWA-MS Spring's Eternal
May 3rd 2015 | Hy-Zaya (c) | def. | Dewey Barnes, Gary Jay, Jake Parnell, Mikey McFinnegan | 5-way | CCW Heavyweight Title
|
FIP Accelerate '15
Jun 5th 2015 | Aaron Solow & Jason Cade | def. (pin) | Gary Jay & Jayson Falcone | | |
IWA-MS Prelude to Death 2015
Jun 14th 2015 | Gary Jay | def. | Aidan Blackhart, Austin Blackburn, Shank Barzini | four-way | |
FIP Declaration of Independence 2015
Jul 3rd 2015 | Chris Hero | def. (pin) | Gary Jay, Martin Stone | three-way | |
EVOLVE #45
Jul 10th 2015 | Caleb Konley | def. (pin) | Gary Jay | | |
FIP EVOLVE #46 Kickoff Show
Jul 11th 2015 | Alexandre Rudolph & Frank Wyatt & Jake Parnell | def. (pin) | Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay & Pierre Abernathy | 6-person tag | |
FIP Heatstroke 2015
Aug 7th 2015 | Gary Jay | def. | Zane Riley | Trailer Park Nation Challenge Match | |
IWA-MS Two Sides Go To War
Sep 25th 2015 | Cash Flo | draw (NC) | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS 19th Anniversary Show
Oct 9th 2015 | Chris Hero & Gary Jay & Ian Rotten & J. C. Rotten & Simon Dean | def. | Christian Rose & Joseph Schwartz & Reed Bentley & The Zodiak & Tripp Cassidy | 10-man tag elimination | |
FIP Fallout 2015 - Day 1
Oct 23rd 2015 | Austin Blackburn & Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay | def. | Chip Day & Jimmy Rave & Murder-1 | 6-person tag | |
FIP Fallout 2015 - Day 2
Oct 24th 2015 | Alex Mason & Rude Boy Riley & Sonny Kiss | def. | Austin Blackburn & Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay | 6-person tag | |
Freelance Wrestling Walk Among Us 2015
Oct 30th 2015 | Suge D. | def. | Arik Cannon, Donovan Danhausen, Gary Jay, Mike Matthews, Silas Young | 6-way elimination | |
IWA-MS November Pain
Nov 20th 2015 | Trik Davis | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Beyond Tournament for Tomorrow 4 - Day 1
Nov 28th 2015 | Angel Ortiz & Mike Draztik | def. | Chuck Taylor & Orange Cassidy, Dorian Graves & V. S. K., Evan Gelistico & Gary Jay | four-way tag | |
IWA-MS Unfinished Business
Dec 4th 2015 | Gary Jay | def. | Slade Sludge | | |
FIP Everything Burns 2016
Feb 12th 2016 | Fred Yehi & Gary Jay | def. | Aaron Solow & Jason Cade | | |
Freelance Wrestling Beautiful Disaster
Mar 11th 2016 | Rob Matter | def. | Chris Castro, Gary Jay, J. J. Garrett, Kobe Durst, Rey Furia, Sean Orleans, The Space Monkey | 8-way | |
WWNLive Mercury Rising 2016
Apr 2nd 2016 | Caleb Konley (c) | def. (pin) | Gary Jay, Jason Cade, Maxwell Chicago | four-way | FIP World Heavyweight Title
|
FIP Declaration of Independence 2016
Jul 8th 2016 | Aaron Solow | def. | Gary Jay | | |
AAW United We Stand 2016
Jul 23rd 2016 | Connor Braxton & Eddie Machete & Scarlett Bordeaux | def. | Angelus Layne & Dominic Garrini & Gary Jay | dark
6-person tag | |
CHIKARA King of Trios 2016 - Night 1
Sep 2nd 2016 | Fire Ant & Silver Ant & Soldier Ant | def. (pin) | Davey Vega & Gary the Barn Owl & Pierre Abernathy | 6-person tag | |
CHIKARA Temple of Doom
Dec 3rd 2016 | Rick Roland & Sloan Caprice & The Big Deal | def. | Davey Vega & Gary the Barn Owl & Pierre Abernathy | 6-person tag | |
IWA-MS Winter Wars 2017
Jan 14th 2017 | Jake Garvin | def. | Gary Jay | | |
IWA-MS Heartbreak 2017
Feb 2nd 2017 | David Starr (c) | def. | Gary Jay | | wXw Shotgun Title
|
IWA-MS Heartbreak: Part Deux
Feb 16th 2017 | Gary Jay | def. | Bret Havoc | | |
Glory Pro Crowning Achievement
Feb 19th 2017 | Myron Reed | def. | Davey Vega, Gary Jay, Jason Roberts, Mat Fitchett, The Space Monkey | 6-Way | |
IWA-MS Ruler of Men
Feb 25th 2017 | Jake Parnell | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Freelance Wrestling Snakes? Why'd It Have to Be Snakes?
Apr 7th 2017 | Chris Castro | def. | Gary Jay, Jake Parnell, PACO | four-way | |
IWA-MS High Times
Apr 20th 2017 | Larry D | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Glory Pro Long May We Reign
May 7th 2017 | Alex Zane | def. | Brandon Espinosa, Ethan Page, Gary Jay, Hakim Zane, Jake Parnell, Jake Something, The Space Monkey, Tyler Matrix | battle royale | |
Glory Pro United Glory
May 26th 2017 | Everett Connors | def. | Aaron Anders, Aaron Dzinic, Brandon Espinosa, Gary Jay, Jake Parnell, Jason Roberts, Logan James, Matt Kenway, Mickey Muscles, Sean Orleans, Tyler Matrix | Gauntlet | |
Glory Pro War Of The New Age
Jul 9th 2017 | Jake Something | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Glory Pro/Pro Wrestling Resurgence No Wasted Luck
Jul 23rd 2017 | Kobe Durst | def. | Brandon Aarons, Donovan Danhausen, Gary Jay, Jake Parnell, Jason Roberts | 6-Way | |
IWA-MS The Boys Are Back In Town
Jul 29th 2017 | Tripp Cassidy | def. | Gary Jay | | |
Gary Jay