| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 ROH Best In The World '16 - Day 2 - TV Tapings
Jun 25th 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. (pin) | Roderick Strong | | |
ROH Aftershock Tour 2016 - TV Tapings
Jul 16th 2016 | Caprice Coleman & Kenny King & Rhett Titus | def. (pin) | Boy #1 & Boy #2 & Dalton Castle | 6-person tag | |
ROH Death Before Dishonor XIV
Aug 19th 2016 | Kazuchika Okada | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle | | |
ROH Death Before Dishonor XIV: TV Tapings
Aug 20th 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. | Caprice Coleman | | |
ROH Field of Honor
Aug 27th 2016 | KUSHIDA | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle | | |
PWG Battle of Los Angeles '16 - Night 1
Sep 2nd 2016 | Adam Cole & Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | def. (pin) | Bobby Fish & Dalton Castle & Kyle O'Reilly | 6-person tag | |
PWG Battle of Los Angeles '16 - Night 2
Sep 3rd 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. (pin) | Tommaso Ciampa | | |
PWG Battle of Los Angeles '16 - Night 3
Sep 4th 2016 | Trevor Lee | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle | | |
ROH Reloaded Tour 2016
Sep 16th 2016 | Colt Cabana & Dalton Castle & Jay Lethal | def. | Adam Cole & Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | 6-person tag | |
ROH Reloaded Tour 2016
Sep 17th 2016 | Jay Briscoe & Mark Briscoe | def. | Colt Cabana & Dalton Castle | | |
ROH Reloaded Tour 2016
Sep 24th 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. (pin) | Jushin Thunder Liger | | |
ROH/NJPW All Star Extravaganza VIII
Sep 30th 2016 | Colt Cabana & Dalton Castle | def. (pin) | Kenny King & Rhett Titus, Keith Lee & Shane Taylor, Hanson & Raymond Rowe | Four Corners Survival Tag | |
ROH All Star Extravaganza VIII - TV Tapings
Oct 1st 2016 | Colt Cabana & Dalton Castle | def. | Sho Tanaka & Yohei Komatsu | | |
ROH Glory By Honor XV - Day 1
Oct 14th 2016 | Jay Briscoe | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle | | |
ROH Glory By Honor XV - Day 2
Oct 15th 2016 | Colt Cabana & Dalton Castle & Jay Briscoe & Mark Briscoe | draw (NC) | Adam Cole & Bobby Fish & Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | 8-person tag | |
ROH Glory By Honor XV - Day 2
Oct 15th 2016 | Matt Jackson (c) & Nick Jackson (c) | def. (pin) | Colt Cabana & Dalton Castle | | ROH World Tag Team Titles
|
ROH Road to Final Battle 2016 - Night 1
Oct 21st 2016 | Hangman Page | def. | Dalton Castle | | |
ROH Road to Final Battle 2016 - Night 2
Oct 22nd 2016 | Colt Cabana & Dalton Castle | def. | Christopher Daniels & Frankie Kazarian | | |
ROH Road to Final Battle 2016 - Night 3: TV Tapings
Oct 29th 2016 | Keith Lee & Shane Taylor | def. (pin) | Colt Cabana & Dalton Castle | | |
ROH Road to Final Battle 2016 - Night 3: TV Tapings
Oct 29th 2016 | Colt Cabana & Dalton Castle | def. (pin) | Ken Dixon & Preston Quinn | | |
ROH Survival of the Fittest 2016 - Day 1
Nov 3rd 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. | Chris Sabin, Rhett Titus | three-way | |
ROH Survival of the Fittest 2016 - Day 2
Nov 4th 2016 | Bobby Fish | def. | Dalton Castle, Jax Dane, Lio Rush, Punishment Martinez, The Panther | 6-man Mayhem Match | |
 NJPW Charity Pro-Wrestling "On The Mat"
Nov 12th 2016 | Hiroshi Tanahashi | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle | | |
 ROH Reach for the Sky - Day 1
Nov 18th 2016 | Marty Scurll | def. (sub) | Dalton Castle | | |
ROH Reach for the Sky - Day 2
Nov 19th 2016 | Christopher Daniels & Frankie Kazarian | def. | Dalton Castle & Delirious | | |
ROH Reach for the Sky - Day 3
Nov 20th 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. (pin) | Lio Rush | | |
ROH Final Battle '16
Dec 2nd 2016 | Dalton Castle | def. (pin) | Colt Cabana | | |
ROH TV Tapings
Dec 4th 2016 | Bobby Fish & Dalton Castle & Kyle O'Reilly | def. | Adam Cole & Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | 6-person tag | |
ROH TV Tapings
Jan 14th 2017 | Caprice Coleman & Kenny King & Rhett Titus | def. | Boy #1 & Boy #2 & Dalton Castle | 6-person tag | |
ROH Undisputed Legacy
Feb 3rd 2017 | Dalton Castle | def. (pin) | Bobby Fish, Jay Lethal | three-way | |
ROH Honor Reigns Supreme
Feb 4th 2017 | Dalton Castle | def. | Donovan Dijak | | |
ROH Steel City Excellence
Feb 11th 2017 | Dalton Castle | def. | Jonathan Gresham | | |
ROH The Experience
Feb 12th 2017 | Cody | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle | | |
 ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2017 - Day 1
Feb 26th 2017 | Hiromu Takahashi & Punisher Martinez & Tetsuya Naito | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle & Hiroshi Tanahashi & Ryusuke Taguchi | 6-person tag | |
ROH/NJPW Honor Rising: Japan 2017 - Day 2
Feb 27th 2017 | BUSHI & EVIL & Hiromu Takahashi & SANADA & Tetsuya Naito | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle & Delirious & Jushin Thunder Liger & Ryusuke Taguchi & Tiger Mask IV | 10-person tag | |
ROH Manhattan Mayhem VI
Mar 4th 2017 | Dalton Castle | def. (pin) | Colt Cabana | | |
ROH Winner Takes All - 15th Anniversary
Mar 10th 2017 | Matt Taven (c) & T. K. O'Ryan (c) & Vinny Marseglia (c) | def. (pin) | Boy #1 & Boy #2 & Dalton Castle | 6-person tag | ROH Six Man Tag Team Championship
|
ROH TV Tapings
Mar 11th 2017 | Christopher Daniels & Dalton Castle & Frankie Kazarian | def. | Adam Cole & Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | 6-person tag | |
ROH Supercard of Honor XI
Apr 1st 2017 | Christopher Daniels (c) | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle | | ROH World Heavyweight Title
|
ROH Charm City Excellence - TV Tapings
Apr 8th 2017 | Adam Cole & Cody | def. (pin) | Christopher Daniels & Dalton Castle | | |
ROH Unauthorized
Apr 28th 2017 | Bully Ray (c) & Jay Briscoe (c) & Mark Briscoe (c) | def. (pin) | Dalton Castle & Hanson & Raymond Rowe | street fight (6-man tag) | ROH Six Man Tag Team Championship
|
ROH Masters of the Craft
Apr 29th 2017 | Christopher Daniels & Dalton Castle & Frankie Kazarian | def. (pin) | Hangman Page & Matt Jackson & Nick Jackson | 6-person tag | |
 ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2017 - Day 1
May 7th 2017 | Boy #1 & Boy #2 & Dalton Castle | def. (pin) | Beretta & Gedo & Rocky Romero | 6-person tag | |
ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2017 - Day 2
May 10th 2017 | Dalton Castle | def. | Bobby Fish | | |
ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2017 - Day 3
May 12th 2017 | Dalton Castle | def. (pin) | Bobby Fish, KUSHIDA, Silas Young | four-way | |
ROH/NJPW War of the Worlds 2017 - Day 4
May 14th 2017 | BUSHI & EVIL & SANADA & Tetsuya Naito | def. (pin) | Bully Ray & Dalton Castle & Jay Briscoe & Mark Briscoe | 8-person tag | |
ROH Windy City Excellence - TV Tapings
Jun 3rd 2017 | Kenny King & Rhett Titus & Shane Taylor | def. | Boy #1 & Boy #2 & Dalton Castle | 6-person tag | |
ROH Gateway to Gold
Jun 4th 2017 | Jay White, Punishment Martinez | draw (DCO) | Cheeseburger, Dalton Castle, Jake Crist, Jonathan Gresham, Kenny King, Sho Tanaka, Will Ferrara, Yohei Komatsu | "Gauntlet For The Gold" | |
Smash (Canada) Gold 2017
Jun 11th 2017 | Mark Haskins | def. | Dalton Castle | | |
ROH Best in the World '17
Jun 23rd 2017 | Boy #1 & Boy #2 & Dalton Castle | def. (pin) | Bully Ray (c) & Jay Briscoe (c) & Mark Briscoe (c) | 6-person tag | ROH Six Man Tag Team Championship
(title change) |
Dalton Castle