| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 NXT TV #606
Apr 16th 2024 | Trick Williams | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | | |
NXT Stand & Deliver 2024
Apr 6th 2024 | Trick Williams | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | | |
NXT Sanford Show
Mar 22nd 2024 | Carmelo Hayes | def. | Je'Von Evans | | |
NXT TV #600 - Roadblock 2024
Mar 5th 2024 | Tony D'Angelo | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | | |
NXT TV #597
Feb 13th 2024 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Joe Gacy | | |
NXT Vengeance Day 2024
Feb 4th 2024 | Baron Corbin & Bron Breakker | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes & Trick Williams | | |
NXT TV #595
Jan 30th 2024 | Carmelo Hayes & Trick Williams | def. (pin) | Cruz Del Toro & Joaquin Wilde | | |
WWE Royal Rumble 2024
Jan 27th 2024 | Cody Rhodes | def. | Andrade, Austin Theory, Bobby Lashley, Bron Breakker, Bronson Reed, Carlito, Carmelo Hayes, CM Punk, Damian Priest, Dominik Mysterio, Drew McIntyre, Finn Bálor, Grayson Waller, Gunther, Ivar, JD McDonagh, Jey Uso, Jimmy Uso, Karrion Kross, Kofi Kingston, Ludwig Kaiser, Omos, Pat McAfee, R-Truth, Ricochet, Sami Zayn, Santos Escobar, Shinsuke Nakamura, The Miz | 30-man Royal Rumble | |
WWE Friday Night Smackdown
Jan 26th 2024 | Austin Theory | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | | |
NXT TV #593
Jan 16th 2024 | Carmelo Hayes & Trick Williams | def. (pin) | Edris Enofé & Malik Blade | | |
WWE Friday Night Smackdown
Jan 12th 2024 | Austin Theory | draw (NC) | Carmelo Hayes | | |
NXT Sebring Show
Jan 6th 2024 | Carmelo Hayes | def. | Luca Crusifino | | |
WWE Friday Night Smackdown
Dec 22nd 2023 | Kevin Owens | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | | |
WWE Friday Night Smackdown Taping
Dec 15th 2023 | Kevin Owens | def. | Carmelo Hayes | | |
WWE Friday Night Smackdown
Dec 15th 2023 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Grayson Waller | | |
NXT Deadline 2023
Dec 9th 2023 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Lexis King | | |
NXT TV #587
Dec 5th 2023 | Tyler Bate | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes, Eddy Thorpe, Joe Coffey | Iron Survivor Challenge | |
NXT Tampa Show
Dec 2nd 2023 | Joe Coffey & Mark Coffey & Wolfgang | def. | Carmelo Hayes & Eddy Thorpe & Trey Bearhill | 6-person tag | |
NXT Venice Show
Nov 18th 2023 | Carmelo Hayes & Channing "Stacks" Lorenzo & Eddy Thorpe & Tony D'Angelo & Von Wagner | def. | Bron Breakker & Bronco Nima & Lucien Price & Noam Dar & Oro Mensah | 10-man tag elimination | |
NXT TV #585 Taping
Nov 14th 2023 | Josh Briggs | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | | |
NXT Lakeland Show
Nov 10th 2023 | Carmelo Hayes | def. | Lexis King | | |
NXT TV #582 - Halloween Havoc 2023 - Day 2
Oct 31st 2023 | Ilja Dragunov (c) | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes | | NXT Championship
|
NXT TV #580
Oct 17th 2023 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Baron Corbin, Dijak | three-way | |
NXT TV #579
Oct 10th 2023 | Carmelo Hayes | def. (pin) | Bron Breakker | | |
NXT No Mercy 2023
Sep 30th 2023 | Ilja Dragunov | def. (pin) | Carmelo Hayes (c) | | NXT Championship
(title change) |
Carmelo Hayes