| card/ date | match | match type | title(s) |
|---|
 TNA Final Resolution '09
Dec 20th 2009 | Abyss & Mick Foley | def. (pin) | Dr. Stevie & Raven | Foley's House of Fun | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Nov 17th 2009 | Daniels | def. | Abyss | commentator: A.J. Styles | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Nov 17th 2009 | Bobby Lashley | def. | Abyss | | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Nov 16th 2009 | Abyss & Mick Foley | def. (DQ) | Dr. Stevie & Raven | | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Nov 3rd 2009 | Dr. Stevie | def. | Abyss | career-threatening match | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Oct 21st 2009 | Abyss | def. | Dr. Stevie | "hardcore" | |
TNA Bound for Glory '09
Oct 18th 2009 | Abyss | def. (pin) | Mick Foley | referee: Dr. Stevie
"Monster's Ball" | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Oct 5th 2009 | Abyss & Matt Morgan | def. | Kurt Angle & Mick Foley | | |
 TNA First Impact Tour '09 - Day 6
Oct 3rd 2009 | Abyss & Brother Devon & Brother Ray | def. | Booker T. & Kurt Angle & Scott Steiner | no disqualification 6-man tag | |
 TNA First Impact Tour '09 - Day 5
Oct 2nd 2009 | Rhino | def. | Abyss | | |
 TNA First Impact Tour '09 - Day 4
Sep 30th 2009 | Rhino | def. | Abyss | | |
TNA First Impact Tour '09 - Day 3
Sep 29th 2009 | Abyss & Brother Devon & Brother Ray | def. | Booker T. & Kurt Angle & Scott Steiner | no disqualification 6-man tag | |
TNA First Impact Tour '09 - Day 2
Sep 26th 2009 | Abyss & Brother Devon & Brother Ray | def. | Booker T. & Kurt Angle & Scott Steiner | no disqualification 6-man tag | |
TNA First Impact Tour '09 - Day 1
Sep 25th 2009 | Abyss & Brother Devon & Brother Ray | def. | Booker T. & Kurt Angle & Scott Steiner | 6-person tag | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Sep 21st 2009 | Booker T. (c) & Scott Steiner (c) | def. | Abyss & Mick Foley | | TNA World Tag Team Titles
|
TNA No Surrender '09
Sep 20th 2009 | Kevin Nash (c) | def. (pin) | Abyss | commentator: Mick Foley | TNA Legends Title
|
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Sep 1st 2009 | Abyss | def. | Dr. Stevie | commentator: Mick Foley | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Aug 18th 2009 | Abyss | def. | Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin | handicap tag | |
TNA Hard Justice '09
Aug 16th 2009 | Abyss | def. (pin) | Jethro Holliday | | |
TNA Victory Road '09
Jul 19th 2009 | Abyss | def. (pin) | Dr. Stevie | no disqualification | |
 1PW Steel City Ice Rage: Total Meltdown
Jul 11th 2009 | Martin Stone (c) | def. | Abyss | | 1PW Title
|
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Jun 23rd 2009 | Kevin Nash | def. | Abyss | | |
TNA Slammiversary '09
Jun 21st 2009 | Abyss & Taylor Wilde | def. (pin) | Daffney & Raven | "Monster's Ball" (tag) | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Apr 22nd 2009 | Abyss | def. | Cody Deaner | | |
TNA Lockdown '09
Apr 19th 2009 | Matt Morgan | def. (pin) | Abyss | Doomsday Chamber of Blood | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Mar 31st 2009 | Abyss & Daffney | def. | Cody Deaner & O. D. B. | | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Mar 17th 2009 | Samoa Joe | def. | A.J. Styles, Abyss, Alex Shelley, Booker T., Chris Sabin, Consequences Creed, Eric Young, Hernandez, Homicide, Jay Lethal, Jeff Jarrett, Kurt Angle, Matt Morgan, Rhino, Scott Steiner, Shane Sewell, Sheik Abdul Bashir, Tetsuya Naito, Yujiro | Gauntlet (20 entrants) | |
TNA Destination X '09
Mar 15th 2009 | Matt Morgan | def. | Abyss | "Match of 10,000 Tacks" | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Feb 24th 2009 | James Storm & Matt Morgan & Robert Roode | def. (pin) | Abyss & Brother Devon & Brother Ray | 6-person tag elimination | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Feb 9th 2009 | James Storm (c) & Robert Roode (c) | def. (pin) | Abyss & Rhino | | TNA World Tag Team Titles
|
TNA Against All Odds '09
Feb 8th 2009 | Abyss | def. (pin) | Matt Morgan | | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Jan 26th 2009 | Abyss | def. (pin) | Scott Steiner | weapons | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Jan 13th 2009 | James Storm & Robert Roode | def. | Abyss & Matt Morgan | "First Blood" | |
TNA iMPACT! Taping
Jan 12th 2009 | Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal | def. (pin) | Abyss & Matt Morgan | | |
TNA Genesis '09
Jan 11th 2009 | James Storm & Robert Roode | def. (pin) | Consequences Creed (c) & Jay Lethal (c), Abyss & Matt Morgan | three-way dance tag | TNA World Tag Team Titles
(title change) |
Abyss during 2009